CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
Average number of requests received
in 6 months, per 100,000 internet users
Figure 5.18: User data requests received by Google from governments
Informal relationships
(1 Jan 2011 ‐ 30 Jun 2012)
between law enforcement and
6.0
Not complied with
private sector organizations can
5.0
Fully or partially complied with
extend more broadly than the
supply of computer data for
4.0
investigations.
During
3.0
information gathering for the
Study, both countries and
2.0
private sector organizations
1.0
reported a wide range of areas
of cooperation. One country in
0.0
RU JP CA MX TR CZ DK NL CH AR IE NO IL BE PL KR CL HU IN ES BR DE GB HK AU IT FR SG PT US
Northern Europe, for example,
Requesting government
reported that ‘Law enforcement
Source: UNODC presentation of Google Transparency Report data.
has an informal working relationship
with the major service providers to update contact information and to develop procedures for the formal exchange of
data.’153 Other countries noted that ‘There are voluntary codes of practice that allow sharing of information,
alongside formal legislation.’154
Several countries reported particular emphasis on relationships with telecommunications
and service provider companies. One country, for instance, highlighted that: ‘Agencies maintain close
relationships with the telecommunications industry – particularly large industry participants. These relationships are
used primarily for discussing practical measures (such as the best procedures for serving warrants, deploying capabilities
and delivering lawfully intercepted information), technical issues (such as the operation of the telecommunications
networks), and policy issues.’155 Information provided by private sector organizations also indicates that
many corporations – and not just electronic service providers – engage in partnerships with law
enforcement. These include for the purposes of sharing general information on cybercrime threats
and trends, and with a view to facilitating reporting of suspected cybercrime cases.156 Public-private
partnerships concerning cybercrime are discussed in broader terms in Chapter Eight (Prevention).
Responses
from
countries to the Study
questionnaire suggest that
informal
relationships
between law enforcement
and service providers are
equally common across
different regions. Figure
5.19 shows that between 50
per cent and 60 per cent of
countries in all regions
reported the existence of
such relationships.157
Figure 5.19: Informal relationships between law
enforcement and service providers
Europe
(n=19)
Asia & Oceania
(n=16)
Yes
Americas
(n=13)
No
Africa
(n=9))
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q103. (n=56)
A number of countries were careful to point out that informal relationships between law
enforcement and service providers involved information sharing ‘not implicating private customer data.’158
153
154
155
156
157
158
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q103.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q40-45.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q103.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q103.
151
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents