CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND
CRIMINAL JUSTICE
This Chapter considers the criminal justice process in cybercrime cases, starting from
the need to identify, collect and analyse electronic evidence through digital forensics. It
examines the admissibility and use of electronic evidence in criminal trials, and
demonstrates how a range of prosecutorial challenges can impact on criminal justice
system performance. It links law enforcement and criminal justice capacity needs with a
view of delivered and required technical assistance activities.
6.1 Introduction to electronic evidence and digital forensics
Key results:
Evidence is the means by which facts relevant to the guilt or innocence of an individual at
trial are established. Electronic evidence is all such material that exists in electronic, or
digital form
Digital forensics is concerned with recovering – often volatile and easily contaminated –
information that may have evidential value
Forensics techniques include the creation of ‘bit-for-bit’ copies of stored and deleted
information, ‘write-blocking’ in order to ensure that original information is not changed,
and cryptographic file ‘hashes,’ or digital signatures, that can demonstrate changes in
information
Electronic evidence in criminal proceedings
Evidence is the means by which facts relevant to the guilt or innocence of an individual at
trial are established. Electronic evidence is all such material that exists in electronic, or digital, form.
As noted in Chapter One (Global connectivity), electronic evidence is central not only to the
investigation and prosecution of forms of cybercrime, but increasingly to crime in general. Legal
frameworks optimized for electronic evidence, together with law enforcement and criminal justice
capacity to identify, collect and analyse electronic evidence, are thus central to an effective crime
response.
During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked about the capacity of law
enforcement authorities and prosecutors to collect and handle electronic evidence. Countries were
also asked about legal frameworks for electronic evidence, including admissibility and evidentiary
laws and rules that apply to electronic evidence. 1 Before consideration of country responses, this
section contains a brief introduction to the nature of electronic evidence and the means through
which it can be collected, including digital forensics.
Generating evidence – User interaction with computer devices produces a wealth of computergenerated digital traces (sometimes called digital fingerprints or artefacts). Computer data and
1
See Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q109-112, and Q143-150.
157
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents