communicating. The following methods have proven helpful: proving possession of the communication device (seizure
upon arrest or execution of a warrant), subscriber information, surveillance (pursuant to a court authorization, where
required), analysis of the content of the communication, and forensic examination of the communication device.’56
Another country observed that ‘there are often multiple different sets of electronic evidence that must be brought
together to place a suspect behind an electronic device at a particular time and place.’57
Most countries reported that specific steps or criteria to establish this link did not exist.
Rather, countries referred to a variety of traditional and cyber-specific techniques to ‘associate the
electronic evidence to a computer system under the control of [the] defendant, or to which [the] defendant has access.
Standard proof techniques apply including motivation, opportunity, corroborative non-electronic evidence, control of
evidence, state-of-mind evidence, and evidence which supports excluding others.’58
Overall, responding countries reported a significant amount of accumulated knowledge in
the area of identification, collection, analysis, and presentation of electronic evidence. Good
practices in this area were highlighted not only by developed countries, but also by a number of
developing countries – indicating increasing levels of global dialogue and dissemination of technical
standards in the areas of electronic evidence. Nonetheless, many institutions in developing countries
– including law enforcement and prosecution authorities – highlight a significant lack of capacity
and resources to fully implement such standards. In addition, in a few countries, legal obstacles such
as the inadmissibility of all electronic evidence, and the inadmissibility of extraterritorial electronic
evidence, present serious obstacles to the prosecution of cybercrime acts.
6.3 Cybercrime and the criminal justice system in practice
Key Results:
Prosecutors report a range of challenges to the successful prosecution of cybercrime,
including sufficiency of legal frameworks, difficulties in the attribution of acts to
individuals, delays due to international cooperation procedures, and evidentiary
challenges
Such challenges are reflected in available statistics on the ratio of suspects to policerecorded acts, and in ‘attrition’ measures that compare the number of convictions with
the number of recorded acts
This section widens the discussion from forensics and electronic evidence to the
performance of the criminal justice system, as a whole, in cybercrime cases. It considers challenges
and good practices reported by prosecutors and courts, and identifies the possible impact of these
on prosecutions and convictions of cybercrime perpetrators.
Prosecution challenges and good practices
Responding countries identified prosecution good practices and challenges across the
criminal justice process, from case intake to final case disposition. Once country, for example,
proposed a comprehensive set of good practices in the areas of case management, evidence
disclosure, and presentation of evidence at trial: ‘1) Collaborate/communicate early on with investigators, IT
56
57
58
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q148.
Ibid.
Ibid.
168
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents