CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
personnel, paralegals and defence counsel. 2) Address quality control safeguards, e.g., business rules. 3) Inventory
investigation and index disclosure. 4) Identify an expert witness who can testify to quality control issues such as
completeness and integrity of prosecution database. 5) Ensure compatibility/interoperability of police/government
computer systems. 6) Meet and confer with defence counsel early in the case. 7) Avoid mixing media. 8) Be able to
defend the disclosure. 9) Think about metadata from the beginning and seek assistance/support from experts. 10)
Ensure e-documents have been properly redacted. 11) Pick the right e-tool to fit the type of evidence you will present at
trial. One size does not fit all. 12) Get the judge’s permission. 13) Identify trial exhibits early, test the equipment in
office/courtroom, have a backup plan, and be prepared.’59
Reported obstacles to successful prosecution generally related to the sufficiency of the legal
framework, identification of suspects, availability and interpretation of evidence, and the proper
evidence handling procedures.
With respect to legislation for procedural powers (discussed in Chapter Five (Law
enforcement and investigations)), responding countries highlighted, for example, that ‘lack of a legal
framework’, ‘lack of procedural legislation’, ‘lack of proper investigatory powers which do not compromise the right to
privacy and free speech in an excessive way,’ and lack of ‘specific legislation on privacy protection’60 complicates
and delays investigations.
Prosecutors also identified the challenge discussed in the previous section of this Chapter of
attribution of evidence of an act to an individual. One country, for example, stated that ‘In general,
attribution is the hardest thing in a cybercrime investigation, so therein lies a practical obstacle to successful
prosecution.’61 Prosecutors from responding countries further highlighted the challenges of cases with
an extraterritorial dimension, including ‘difficulty in obtaining evidence requiring international cooperation of
other countries,’ and ‘delay in the investigation and prosecution of cybercrime offences’ due to formal international
cooperation processes, such as mutual legal assistance.62
Evidentiary issues were reported as major barriers to successful prosecution, including ‘the
large volume of evidence’, ‘the short period of time during which service providers store information needed for
investigation purposes’ and ‘maintaining integrity of electronic evidence from the time of seizure to the point of
completion of the case’, ‘failure to establish chain of custody of evidence, and lack of proper storage facilities to maintain
evidence.’63 ‘The production of cybercrime evidence is still a challenge in court’ and ‘lack of integrity of evidence from
improper handling thereof by law enforcement’64 were also identified as particularly challenging by several
countries.
Countries repeatedly reinforced the importance of evidence collection and presentation.
‘Close working relationships on the prosecution team between the prosecutor and investigator that result in collection of
all relevant properly authenticated evidence’65 are essential to success in prosecution. ‘Hardware, and where
appropriate software, are to be seized from the accused as quickly as is lawfully possible… followed by rapid
evaluation by specially-trained highly skilled staff or external specialists.’66 ‘Separate identification and tracking of all
the relevant computer documents/images,’67 a ‘clear chain of custody of exhibits,’68 and ‘developing policies in
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q142.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q142.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q183.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q142.
Ibid.
169
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents