CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION jurisdiction is needed.13 Principles of criminal jurisdiction Principle of territoriality (Objective territorial principle) Effects Doctrine Principle of nationality (Active) (Passive) Habitual residence Protective principle Principle of universality A state can prosecute activities upon its territory, even in cases where an offender is a foreign citizen If the perpetrator is outside of the territory, territorial jurisdiction nonetheless includes where one of the constituent elements of the offence, and more especially its effects, take place within the territory. The objective territoriality principle thus ensures that both the state where the behaviour commenced, and the state where the offence was concluded may validly try the alleged perpetrator14 Jurisdiction is established over foreign conduct that produces substantial effects within the territory15 Jurisdiction is established depending upon the nationality of the individual concerned16 Jurisdiction is established based on the nationality of the offender, wherever the crime is committed Jurisdiction is established based on the nationality of the victim, wherever the crime is committed Jurisdiction is established based on the place of habitual residence of the offender17 Jurisdiction is established where a criminal act abroad is derogatory to the security of the state concerned and/or touches upon its vital interests18 Jurisdiction is established over any person accused of committing a small number of ‘international crimes,’ such as piracy, war crimes and grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, regardless of the territory or the nationality of individuals involved.19 The principle is usually limited to situations where the state with territorial jurisdiction is unable or unwilling to prosecute It is important to note that the use of such forms of jurisdiction by countries – either on the basis of national law or international agreements – does not automatically override the operation of sovereignty and non-interference principles. The physical conduct of a criminal investigation on foreign soil (under the protective principle or passive nationality principle, for example) still requires the consent of the foreign state.20 The jurisdiction that a state claims to assert is thus related, but separable, from the question of non-interference and infringement of sovereignty. International legal assistance regimes In order to manage the process of consent for the conduct of law enforcement and criminal justice investigations outside a state’s territory, a number of legal and informal arrangements exist between states, at the bilateral and multilateral level. Treaties concerning the formal surrender of suspected persons from one country to another, for example, are some of the oldest known 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Epping, V. and Gloria, C., 2004. Der Staat im Völkerrecht. In: Ipsen, K., (ed.) Völkerrecht. 5th ed. Munich: C.H. Beck. pp.321-22. Lotus case, PCIJ, Series A, No. 10, 1927, 23, 30. See Hayashi, M., 2006. Objective Territorial Principle or Effects Doctrine? Jurisdiction and Cyberspace. In Law 6:285. See Shaw, M., 2003. International Law. p.579 et seq. and Cassese, A., 2005. International Law. pp.451 et seq. Jeschek, H. H., Weigend, T., 1996. Lehrbuch des Strafrechts. Allgemeiner Teil. 5th edn. Berlin: Duncker & Humbold. p.169. Simma, B., Mueller, A., 2012. Exercise and the Limits of Jurisdiction. In: Crawford, J. and Koskenniemi, M., (eds.) The Cambridge Companion to International Law. pp.134,143. Cassese, A., 2005. International Law. pp.451-452. Brownlie, I., 2003. Principles of Public International Law. 6th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p.306. For a national legal example of the prohibition of ‘unlawful activities on behalf of a foreign State’ see Art. 271, Swiss Criminal Code: ‘Any person who carries out activities on behalf of a foreign State on Swiss territory without lawful authority, where such activities are the responsibility of a public authority of a public official… shall be liable to a custodial sentence.’ For a practical example of the approach of another to foreign criminal investigators, see: http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/interpol/fcip-pcece-eng.htm 185

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents