Total number of removal requests
figure 2.11 demonstrates that content involving violence; privacy and security concerns;
impersonation; hate speech; defamation; and government criticism is considered a target for removal
from the internet. The total number of removal requests is comparable across regions. For all
regions, removal requests most commonly involve material related to defamation, and privacy and
security. Linked with this pattern, during information gathering for the Study, a number of countries
in Northern Africa and South-Eastern Asia noted cybercrime trends of ‘more and more frequent use of
social networks for defamation and propaganda,’ as well as ‘an upward trend in acts related to reputation and
privacy’ and ‘libellous online postings.’58 As discussed in Chapter Four of this Study (Criminalization),
while online global
content cannot be
Figure 2.11: Content removal requests received by Google from governments
2010‐2012
judged in terms of a
single morality, a
1800
Other
high threshold is
Government Criticism
1600
demanded when the
Pornography
1400
National Security
tool of criminal law
Violence
1200
is used to limit
Impersonation
freedoms
of
1000
Privacy and Security
expression.59
Hate Speech
800
Defamation
Child
600
pornography – One
400
content type which
200
may – indeed, must –
0
be subject to criminal
Europe
Asia and Oceania
Americas
measures, however,
Source: UNODC elaboration of Google Transparency Report.
is child pornography.
During information
gathering for the Study, acts involving child pornography were reported to constitute almost one
third of the most commonly encountered cybercrimes for countries in Europe and the Americas.
The proportion was lower – at around 15 per cent – for countries in Asia and Oceania.60 Since 2009,
almost 1,000 unique commercial child pornography websites have been identified, each with its own
distinctive name and ‘brand.’ Some 440 of these were active during 2011.61 Each website is a
gateway to hundreds or thousands of individual images or videos of child sexual abuse. They are
often supported by layers of payment mechanism, content stores, membership systems and
advertising. Recent developments include the use of sites that when loaded directly display legal
content, but when loaded via a particular referrer gateway site enable access to child pornography
images. In addition, single law enforcement operations against P2P filesharing of child pornograpy
have identified IP addresses to the order of millions offering child pornography.62
Intellectual property infringement – Intellectual property rights are the rights given to persons
over the creations of their minds. They usually give the creator an exclusive right over the use of his
or her creation for a certain period of time. Almost all materials in which such rights vest can
conceivably be made available online – whether literary or artistic works, sound recordings,
distinctive signs such as trademarks, details of inventions protected by patents, industrial designs or
58
59
60
61
62
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q81 and Q85.
See Chapter Four (Criminalization), Section 4.3 International human rights law and criminalization, Limitations on freedom of
expression and international law.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q81.
Internet Watch Foundation, 2011. Annual Report 2011.
See http://www.justice.gov/psc/docs/natstrategyreport.pdf
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents