CHAPTER TWO: THE GLOBAL PICTURE Moreover, the application of current models of organized crime to ‘online’ activity is not without its challenges. Traditional features of organized crime such as the use of violence and control of territory are difficult to translate to cybercrime activity. In addition, issues of traditional ‘governance’ of organized criminal groups, including trust and enforcement, may not be easily mediated in an environment of online forums or chat rooms. Nonetheless, what individuals can do, organizations can also do – and often better. The internet and related technologies lend themselves well to broader coordination between individuals across a dispersed area – opening up possibilities for shorter-lived ‘swarm’ criminal associations, and divergence from traditional models such as standard and regional hierarchy-based groups. 103 As discussed below, in a relatively short period of time, cybercrime has transformed from a low volume crime committed by an individual specialist offender to a common high volume crime, ‘organized and industrial like.’ 104 One recent study that reviewed a sample of 500 recorded cybercrime offences, estimated that upwards of 80 per cent of digital crime may now entail some form of organized activity. 105 An upper estimate for organized crime involvement in cybercrime may be 90 per cent. 106 The EUROPOL iOCTA claims that where not already the case, in the near future the ‘vast majority’ of investigations into transnational organized crime will necessitate some form of internet investigation. Although purposefully biased towards organized crime cases, the UNODC Digest of Organized Crime Cases concludes that the presence of an organized criminal group as a constant factor in all cybercrime cases examined ‘substantially diminishes the role of isolated hackers as main actors in cybercrime.’ 107 The Digest also notes that the nature of cybercrime offences ‘necessarily requires the organization of many means and human resources.’ A number of responding countries also mentioned an increasing involvement of organized criminal groups in cybercrime during the last five years. One country in Western Africa, for example, noted the ‘development of cybercrime groups that are more and more organized and possessing a transnational dimension.’ A country in South America stated ‘cybercrime went from an offence committed by an isolated criminal to crime committed by criminal organizations,’ and a country in South-Eastern Asia concluded ‘cybercrime has become syndicated with respective individuals engaged in different specialized roles.’ 108 Organized criminal groups can therefore be considered, at the very least, as significant cybercrime actors. The limited empirical evidence nonetheless requires caution – regarding conclusions both as to the proportion of organized crime involvement, and its form and structure. Computer technology has empowered individuals as never before. One study on enrolled student cybercrime suspects, for example, suggests that 77 per cent acted alone, rather than in a group.109 One responding country in Western Asia also reported that most cybercrime acts were ‘of an individual nature carried out by people for personal purposes and not in the form of organizations or groups.’ As noted above, such conclusions may be heavily dependent upon conceptions of ‘cybercrime’ applied, and the nature of cases that come to the attention of national authorities. 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 BAE Systems Detica and London Metropolitan University, 2012. Organised Crime in the Digital Age. Moore, T., Clayton, R., Anderson, R., 2009. The economics of online crime. Journal of Economic perspectives, 32(3):3-4. BAE Systems Detica and London Metropolitan University, 2012. Organised Crime in the Digital Age. Norton Cybercrime Report. 2011. Available at: http://us.norton.com/content/en/us/home_homeoffice/media/pdf/cybercrime_report/Norton_USA-Human%20ImpactA4_Aug4-2.pdf UNODC, 2012. Digest of Organized Crime Cases: A compilation of cases with commentaries and lessons learned. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q85. Lu, C.C., Jen, W.Y., Chang, W. and Chou, S., 2006. Cybercrime & Cybercriminals. Journal of Computers, 1(6):11-18. The study also finds that 63 per cent of all cybercrime suspects acted independently. It notes, however, that complicity is difficult to detect and it is likely that some cases of cybercrime identified as being independently perpetrated may actually be group perpetrated. 45

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents