Overall, while criminal groups likely predominate in certain forms of cybercrime, it is clear that all
typologies – including individual perpetrators – must be taken into account. The case examples
contained in boxes in this Chapter, for example, demonstrate something of the range of perpetrator
and group characteristics.
Group structure – One recent analysis of organized crime and cybercrime proposes a typology
based on the degree of involvement of groups in online (as opposed to offline) activities and the
structure of associations within the group.110 Type I groups are suggested to have activities largely
centred upon or directed at digital environments. Type II groups are proposed to have activities
which switch between and across on and offline settings. Type I are further divided as ‘swarms’
(online-centric, dissociated structures) and ‘hubs’ (online-centric, associated structures).
From a law enforcement perspective, the de-centred, cellular nature of ‘swarms,’ with no
obvious
chain
of
command, may present
Figure 2.15: Structures of organized criminal groups engaged in cybercrime
policing difficulties. On
Swarms
the other hand, the fact
(eg. 'hacktivist' groups)
that swarms are often
Type I
(Largely online
amateur, with weaker
activities)
Hubs
checks
on
(eg.
'scareware'
operations)
‘membership,’
may
Organized crime and
represent
policing
cybercrime
Clustered hybrids
opportunities.
In
(eg. 'carding' forums and
skimmers)
contrast, ‘hubs’ can be
Type II
more
difficult
to
(Both online and
offline activities)
Extended hybrids
penetrate, but possess a
(eg.phone theft and online
clear
command
trading)
structure
and
key
Source: BAE Detica/LMU
operatives on which law
enforcement efforts can
focus. Type II clustered and extended hybrids may have confusing, multiple-link-based structures
that can only be targeted through individual law enforcement operations. The fact that such groups
may be co-ordinated in some degree, however, presents opportunities for sequential action against
(otherwise) individual criminal operations.111 In addition, a proposed ‘Type III’ group perpetrates
activities that are predominantly offline but increasingly intersect or are mediated through digital
environments.112 Evidence suggests that – while organizational structures often cross-cut in highly
fluid ways – all of these group structures play a role in cybercrime offending. Hubs and clustered
extended hybrids likely account for over 60 per cent of structures.113
Organized crime and cybercrime markets – Organizational structures for financial-driven
cybercrime, such as theft of banking details and credit card numbers, have been subject to particular
analysis. A cybercrime ‘black market’ has been characterized in which groups and individuals with
different roles and sometimes acting in multiple roles (including ‘programmers’, ‘distributers’,
‘technical experts’, ‘hackers’, ‘fraudsters’, ‘hosters’, ‘cashers’, ‘money mules’, ‘tellers’ and ‘leaders’)114
interact in the process of malware creation, computer infection (such as through phishing emails),
110
111
112
113
114
BAE Systems Detica and London Metropolitan University, 2012. Organised Crime in the Digital Age.
Ibid. p.51.
Ibid. p.52.
Ibid. p.60.
See http://www.fbi.gov/news/speeches/the-cyber-threat-whos-doing-what-to-whom
46
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents