CHAPTER TWO: THE GLOBAL PICTURE
botnet management, harvesting of personal and financial data, data sale, and ‘cashing-out’ of
financial information.115
One mode of association within this market is the use of underground forums (often
facilitated by anonymity services or ‘onion routing’ such as Tor) for the exchange of information
and mediating the sale of consulting
services, infection/spreading services,
Perpetrator interactions
botnet rental, spam services, hosting,
Complaints issued by law enforcement authorities in a country in
e-mail lists, and financial details.116
North America in the course of criminal proceedings against a
While such markets can involve a
group of alleged transnational cybercrime perpetrators reveals the
large number of total individuals,
nature of perpetrator interactions within cybercrime markets. The
associations may be transient –
extract below is from instant messages, or ‘chats’ obtained pursuant
to a series of search warrants:
particularly in the case of money
mules and criminal ‘business’
11:55:42:68 PM CC-4
how much your Trojan will cost me?
transactions, such as botnet rental
11:56:33:00 PM Alias-1 2k a month including hosting and
support
from one individual or group to
…
another. Botnets are used to commit
11:56:55:38 PM Alias-1 you can give it [meaning access to the
botnet] to different people, checker and
attacks against information systems
co-workers
and to steal data, and are offered at
…
relatively low cost, benefiting from
12:28:22:32 AM Alias-1 …I have .exe which gives at least 200300 bucks from 1k of downloads for
the turnover based on the number of
[different countries] [meaning [the
‘customers.’ For example, a server
botnet] will provide 200USD-300USD in
stolen proceeds for every 1000 sets of
with stored malware, exploit kits or
stolen information from victims in
botnet components costs anywhere
[different countries]]
from $80 to $200 a month. One
Source:
botnet administration pack, known as
http://www.justice.gov/usao/nys/pressreleases/January13/GoziVirusDoc
uments/Kuzmin,%20Nikita%20Complaint.pdf
the Eleonore Exploit Pack, has a retail
value of $1,000. Renting a botnet of
between 10 and 20 computers,
administered using this pack, costs an average of $40 a day. A Zeus kit v1.3 costs $3,000 to
$4,000.117 These costs are relatively low compared to the potential financial gain, which may amount
to anywhere from tens of thousands to tens of millions of dollars.
The market as a whole is not a single criminal group enterprise. Rather, it can be
characterized as a ‘social network of individuals engaged in organized criminal activity.’118 Certain
individuals and small groups – such as the original programmers of malware, and botnet C&C
owners – may represent key points within the market, around which other individuals, swarms, and
hubs turn. Based on law enforcement investigations and arrests to date, those responsible for
creating and managing key components of the market, such as botnets, appear to act in
comparatively small groups, or even individually.119 Out of a cohort of groups120 identified and
115
116
117
118
119
See, for example, Fortinet, 2013. Fortinet 2013 Cybercrime Report; Panda Security, 2010. The Cybercrime Black Market: Uncovered; and
Group IB, 2011. State and Trends of the Russian Digital Crime Market.
See, for example, Motoyama, M. et al., 2011. An Analysis of Underground Forums. IMC 2011, 2-4 November 2011, Berlin; and StoneGross, B. et al., 2011. The Underground Economy of Spam: A Botmaster’s Perspective of Coordinating Large-Scale Spam Campaigns.
ESET Latin America’s Lab, 2010. ESET, Trends for 2011: Botnets and Dynamic Malware. Available at:
http://go.eset.com/us/resources/white-papers/Trends-for-2011.pdf
See, for example, Spapens, T., 2010. Macro Networks, Collectives, and Business Processes: An Integrated Approach to Organized
Crime. European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, 18:285-215.
See, for example, Bredolab botnet creator (http://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/05/23/bredolab-jail-botnet/); Kelihos botnet
creator (http://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/01/24/microsoft-kelihos-botnet-suspect/);
Mariposa botnet creator (http://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/08/07/mariposa-botnet-trial/); and
SpyEye convictions (http://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2012/07/01/uk-cops-announce-sentencing-of-baltic-malware-trio/)
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents