CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
than by criminal legislation. In addition, criminal statutes often refer to underlying civil and
administrative law standards, such as in the areas of copyright law or data protection law. Combined
provisions can also provide for criminal, administrative and civil liability at the same time. Thus,
legislation relevant to cybercrime may address a wide range of issues, including: criminalization of
particular conduct; police investigative powers; issues of criminal jurisdiction; admissibility of
electronic evidence; data protection responsibilities of electronic service providers; and mechanisms
of international cooperation in criminal matters involving cybercrime.
This breadth of areas was reflected by responding countries. When asked to report
legislation relevant to cybercrime, countries referred to a number of laws, including: criminal codes;
laws on high-tech crime; criminal procedural codes; laws on wiretapping; evidence acts; laws on
electronic communications; laws on security of information technologies; laws on personal data and
information protection; laws on electronic transactions; cybersecurity acts; and laws on international
cooperation.5
Figure 3.1 shows the areas covered by legislation reported by countries through the Study
questionnaire. The data represents the distribution of over 250 reported existing, and over 100 new
or planned pieces of legislation.6 Criminalization is the predominant area of focus for both existing,
and new or planned legislation. As discussed in Chapter Four (Criminalization), this includes both
cyber-specific and general criminal provisions. The fact that criminalization represents the most
frequent area for new
Figure 3.1: Cybercrime legislation areas
or planned legislation
indicates a continued
38%
Criminalization
27%
focus of countries on
15%
Investigative measures
the development of
17%
new
cyber-specific
11%
Jurisdiction
14%
offences, and/or the
Existing legislation
9%
adaptation
or
Electronic evidence
13%
amendment of existing
New or planned legislation
6%
International cooperation
12%
general offences.
9%
Prevention
6%
A
clear
5%
pattern, however, is a
Public‐private cooperation
5%
reduction
in
the
6%
Other
relative proportion of
5%
new
or
planned
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q12 and Q14. (n=55,36; r=262,111)
legislation (compared
to existing legislation) that concerns criminalization, and an increase in relative attention to other
areas, such as investigative measures, jurisdiction, electronic evidence, and, notably, international
cooperation. This may indicate a trend – at least amongst responding countries – towards increasing
recognition of the need for cybercrime legislation across a spectrum of legislative areas.
By way of introduction to these legislative areas, this section briefly introduces relevant legal
considerations for each.
Criminalization - The principle of nullum crimen sine lege (no crime without law) requires that
the conduct constituting any criminal offence must be described clearly by law.7 As discussed above,
5
6
7
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q12.
Legislation reported in response to Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q12 and 14.
While, in common law countries, judicial competencies for developing and extending criminal law have traditionally been greater,
modern approaches to criminalization require statute-based law even in core common law systems. See U.S. v. Hudson and Goodwin,
53
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents