When it comes to cybercrime, some remaining historical legal differences in national criminal procedure law certainly persist.25 Nonetheless, differences in the overall content of the criminal law often depend less on the particular ‘legal family’ – be it civil or common law – and more on prevailing socio-cultural and constitutional orders. The placement of varying emphasis, for example, on values such as freedom of expression and privacy, or on the individual or community, can have a significant influence on policy and criminalization outcomes. In the context of cybercrime, this can lead to different legal results in areas such as regulation of obscene material;26 balances between freedom of speech and unacceptable expression;27 levels of access to internet content;28 rules and obligations for internet service providers;29 and safeguards and limitations on intrusive law enforcement investigations.30 In addition to socio-cultural and constitutional effects, the impact on legal drafting processes of simple historical coincidences, the impact of views of individual experts, and differing evaluations of best practice, should not be underestimated. Technical legal differences that arise from such effects, as well as from legal procedural heritages, may be significantly more straightforward to account for and to address, than those that derive from socio-cultural and constitutional orders. Harmonization of laws Such differences lead to the question of whether, and if so, how far, national legal differences in cybercrime laws can and should be reduced. In other words, how important is it to harmonize cybercrime laws? This can be undertaken in a number of ways, including through both binding and non-binding international or regional initiatives. The basis of harmonization may be a single national approach (with all others revising their laws in line), or, more often, common legal elements identified in the law of a number of states, or expressed within a multilateral instrument – such as a treaty or non-binding international standard. Indeed, as discussed further below, one of the aims of international law is to achieve harmonization of national laws. During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked about perceived degrees of harmonization of cybercrime legislation, and about successes and limitations of harmonization, and approaches used to maintain national legal traditions during harmonization processes.31 A number of countries, in Asia and the Americas in particular, highlighted that while harmonization was important, the process was subject to some important limitations. These included ‘conflict… with constitutional requirements,’ requirements that harmonization should not be ‘in conflict with Basic Law and Sharia’, needs for ‘contextual application’ of harmonized standards, and issues of the existence of both federal and state legislation within a country.32 Countries also reported successes in harmonization of cybercrime legislation. Countries highlighted, for example, that harmonization was part of a ‘comprehensive approach to include substantive and procedural rules of law’, and that national legal traditions 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 On the evolving and heterogeneous nature of procedural law, see Legeais, R., 2004. Grands systèmes de droit contemporains. Paris: Litec, p.389. See, for instance, Segura-Serrano, A., 2006. Internet Regulation and the Role of International Law. In: Von Bogdandy, A., Wolfrum, R. (eds.) Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law, 10(2006):191-272; Edick, D.A. 1998. Regulation of Pornography on the Internet in the United States and the United Kingdom: A Comparative Analysis. Boston College International & Comparative. Law Review 21(2):437-460. See Report of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression. A/67/357, 7 September 2012. Ibid. See Report of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression. A/HRC/17/27, 16 May 2011. For instance, regarding investigations into computer-related acts in support of terrorism offences, see UNODC. 2012. The use of the Internet for terrorist purposes. paras 35, 106, 110. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q16 and Q17. Ibid. Q16. 58

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents