A/76/136
target the essential medical services of another State could all, depending on the
circumstances, be in violation of the international law prohibition on intervention.
10. The International Court of Justice has established that a prohibited intervention
is one bearing on matters which each State is permitted, by the principle of State
sovereignty, to decide freely. Sovereignty, as a general principle, is a fundamental
concept in international law. The United Kingdom recalls that any prohibition on the
activities of States whether in relation to cyberspace or other matters, must be clearly
established either in customary international law or in a treaty binding upon the States
concerned. The United Kingdom does not consider that the general concept of
sovereignty by itself provides a sufficient or clear basis for extrapolating a specific
rule or additional prohibition for cyber conduct going beyond that of non-intervention
referred to above. At the same time, the United Kingdom notes that differing
viewpoints on such issues should not prevent States from assessing whether particular
situations amount to internationally wrongful acts and arriving at common
conclusions on such matters.
STATE RESPONSIBILITY & ATTRIBUTION
11. A State is responsible under international law for cyber activities that are
attributable to it in accordance with the rules on State responsibility. The
responsibility of a State for activities that occur on its territory including in relation
to activities in cyberspace is therefore determined in accordance with the rules of
international law on State responsibility. As well as bearing responsibility for acts of
its organs and agents, a State is also responsible in accordance with international law
where, for example, a person or a group of persons acts on its instructions or under
its direction or control.
12. UNGGE Norm 13(c) provides that States should not knowingly allow their
territory to be used for internationally wrongful acts using information and
communications technology. This norm provides guidance on what may be expected
to constitute appropriate State behaviour. The UK recognises the importance of States
taking appropriate, reasonably available, and practicable steps within their capacities
to address activities that are acknowledged to be harmful in order to enhance the
stability of cyberspace in the interest of all States. But the fact that States have
referred to this as a non-binding norm indicates that there is not yet State practice
sufficient to establish a specific customary international law rule of ‘due diligence’
applicable to activities in cyberspace.
13. The term ‘attribution’ is used in relation to cyberspace in both a legal and
non-legal sense. It is used in a legal sense to refer to identifying those who are
responsible for an internationally wrongful act. It is also used in a non-legal sense to
describe the identification of actors (including non-state actors) who have carried out
cyber conduct which may be regarded as hostile or malicious but does not necessarily
involve an internationally wrongful act.
14. For the UK, there are technical and diplomatic considerations in determining
whether to attribute publicly such activities in cyberspace. The decision whether to
make a public attribution statement is a matter of policy. Each case is considered on
its merits. The UK will publicly attribute conduct in furtherance of its commitment
to clarity and stability in cyberspace or where it is otherwise in its interests to do so.
15. Whatever the nature of the attribution, there is no general legal obligation
requiring a State to publicly disclose any underlying information on which its
decision to attribute conduct is based.
COUNTERMEASURES
21-09670
117/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents