A/76/136
involvement in the conflict may be inferred or acts that could be deemed in favour of
a party to the conflict. In its relations with parties to the armed conflict the neutral state
is required to treat all parties equally in order to maintain its neutrality. A state may
not, for example, deny access to its IT systems to one party to the conflict but not to
the other. In its response to the above-mentioned advisory report by the AIV/CAVV,
the government noted that, ‘In an armed conflict involving other parties, the
Netherlands can protect its neutrality by impeding the use by such parties of
infrastructure and systems (e.g. botnets) on Dutch territory. Constant vigilance, as
well as sound intelligence and a permanent scanning capability, are required here.’ 159
IHL also lays down specific rules regarding attacks aimed at persons or objects,
which apply equallyto cyber operations carried out as part of an armed conflict. 160
When planning and carrying out such operations, states must act in accordance with,
for example, the principles of distinction and proportionality, as well as the obligation
to take precautionary measures.
Human rights
Human rights are an important component of international law which are laid
down in a number of instruments, such as UN treaties and the European Convention
on Human Rights (ECHR). Human rights include the right to life, the prohibition of
torture and inhuman or degrading treatment, and the right to a fair trial.
States have a duty to respect and protect the human rights of every person within
their jurisdiction.This implies not only a ‘negative’ duty – i.e. to refrain from acts in
violation of human rights – but also a ‘positive’ duty to ensure that people can genuinely
exercise their rights and defend themselves against violations by others. It is for
instance not sufficient for the Dutch government to respect the privacy of Dutch
citizens. It must also take measures to ensure that, for example, companies respect the
privacy of their customers.
Most human rights are not absolute. This means that some restriction of rights is
permissible under certain circumstances. For example, states may criminalise hate
speech or incitement to violence, even though doing so has implications for certain
individuals in terms of their freedom of expression.The assessment of whether a given
restriction is justified depends on the treaty provision concerned.In most cases, however,
the factors to be weighed include whether the restriction serves a legitimate purpose, has
a valid legal basis and is necessary and proportionate. In addition, in an emergency
situation, the observance of a limited number of human rights may be partly suspended
for a limitedperiod. One example is the introduction of a curfew when in a state of war.
Human rights are just as valid in cyberspace as they are in the physical domain.
There is no difference between online and offline rights. This has been recognised by
the United Nations General Assembly, among others. 161
However, it is clear that ongoing digitalisation and technological advances are
raising new questions and presenting new challenges when it comes to the application
of human rights. The increased scope for collecting, storing and processing data
creates issues concerning the right to privacy. Similarly, the increased options for
people to express their views viaonline platforms raise questions with regard to the
__________________
159
160
161
60/142
‘Cyber Warfare’, Advisory report no 77, AIV/no. 22, CAVV December 2011, p. 26.
Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 relating to International
Armed Conflicts (Protocol I), Bern, 8 June 1977, article 49; Tallinn Manual 2.0, Rule 92. It is
beyond the scope of this letter to consider the technical debate on the difference between a cyber
operation and a cyberattack in the context of an armed conflict.
See e.g. ‘The Right to Privacy in the Digital Age’, General Assembly Res. 68/167, para. 3, UN
Doc. A/RES/68/167 (December 2013).
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents