Key Provisioning
The provisioning of cryptographic keys into devices is a
critical initial step in establishing a security baseline. This
provisioning is done in one of three ways224:
– Pre-provisioning: Secure Elements (SEs) destined for IoT
devices are typically purchased from a silicon vendor with
all required keys pre-provisioned on the chip by this
vendor. This means that the IoT device maker does not
need to deal with provisioning keys for his device, but the
SE approach comes with downsides such as increased
costs and complexity in purchasing, supply chain and
inter-chip interfacing.
– Key Injection: Cryptographic keys can be injected into a
device at different points in the supply chain. After
injection, the keys are stored on the device. Most widely
used embedded key storage methods are based on NonVolatile Memory (NVM) such as Electrically Erasable
Programmable Read Only Memory (EEPROM), Flash, or
One-Time Programmable (OTP) memory such as fuses
and anti-fuses. With these memory types, the
provisioning of root keys comes with trade-offs among
flexibility, key-exposure liability, cost, reliability and
security.
Pre-provisioning: The use of a
secure element may increase
cost and complexity
– On-board Key Generation: An internal Random Number
Generator (RNG) on the chip can derive a random secret
and use it to generate cryptographic keys. This method
increases the flexibility within the supply chain compared
to key injection (assuming the target chip contains a
random number generator), but it does not make any
difference regarding how the root key is stored.
5.8.2 Key Findings
– A hardware RoT is the only immutable trust anchor; the
chain of trust should build on a hardware RoT. Currently,
only 4% of IoT devices use a hardware RoT.225
– RoT-based cybersecurity can be provided by several
solutions including Secure Elements, TPMs, TEEs, Cisco
Trust Anchor, Microsoft’s Pluton Security Subsystem, and
SIM cards.
– Solutions to secure firmware and booting are being
proposed as a joint effort of the hardware and software
industry, however, their adoption for IoT devices is still in
the initial stage.
Key injection: non-volatile
memory can be provisioned with
keys early in the supply chain
On-board Key Generation: Using
an RNG, keys can be generated
internally on the chip
Figure 20: Key Provisioning (Source: Intrinsic ID)
224 Protecting the IoT With Invisible Keys, Intrinsic ID Whitepaper, 2018
225 IoT Security from Design to Lifecycle Management, An Embedded Perspective; ABI Research, 2018.
67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents