AUSTRALIA’S INTERNATIONAL CYBER AND CRITICAL TECH ENGAGEMENT STRATEGY
‘[A] state may act in anticipatory
self-defence against an armed
attack when the attacker is clearly
committed to launching an armed
attack, in circumstances where the
victim will lose its last opportunity
to effectively defend itself unless
it acts. This standard reflects the
nature of contemporary threats,
as well as the means of attack
that hostile parties might deploy.
Consider, for example, a threatened
armed attack in the form of an
offensive cyber operation, …which
could cause large-scale loss of
human life and damage to critical
infrastructure. Such an attack might
be launched in a split-second. Is
it seriously to be suggested that
a state has no right to take action
before that split-second?’
Harmful conduct in cyberspace that
does not constitute a use of force may
still constitute a breach of the duty not
to intervene in the internal or external
affairs of another State. This obligation is
encapsulated in Article 2(7) of the Charter
and in customary international law.
98
A prohibited intervention is one that
interferes by coercive means, either
directly or indirectly, in matters that
a State is permitted by the principle
of State sovereignty to decide freely.
Such matters include a State’s economic,
political, social systems and foreign
policy. Coercive means are those that
effectively deprive the State of the
ability to control, decide upon or govern
matters of an inherently sovereign
nature. Accordingly, the use by a hostile
State of cyber activities to manipulate the
electoral system to alter the results of an
election in another State, intervention in
the fundamental operation of Parliament,
or in the stability of States’ financial
systems would constitute a violation
of the principle of non-intervention.
2. International humanitarian law
(jus in bello) and international human
rights law
International humanitarian law (IHL)
(including the principles of humanity,
necessity, proportionality and
distinction) applies to cyber activities
within an armed conflict.
Australia considers that, if a cyber
activity rises to the same threshold
as that of a kinetic ‘attack’ (or act of
violence) under IHL, the rules governing
such attacks during armed conflict will
apply to those kinds of cyber activities.
Applicable IHL rules will also apply to
cyber activities in an armed conflict that
do not constitute or rise to the level of an
‘attack’, including the principle of military
necessity and the general protections
afforded to the civilian population
and individual civilians with respect
to military operations.
The IHL principle of proportionality
prohibits the launching of an attack
which may be expected to cause
incidental loss of civilian life, injury to
civilians, damage to civilian objects,
or a combination thereof, which would
be excessive in relation to the concrete
and direct military advantage anticipated.
The IHL principle of military necessity
states that a combatant is justified in
using those measures, not forbidden by
international law, which are indispensable
for securing complete submission of
an enemy at the soonest moment.
The principle cannot be used to justify
actions prohibited by law, as the means
to achieve victory are not unlimited.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents