Integrating sanctions with other UN responses
55
The mandates of sanctions monitoring and humanitarian actors are
mutually reinforcing notwithstanding potential areas of tension that may
complicate cooperation. Poor understanding of the objectives of sanctions
may impede cooperation among sanctions monitoring and humanitarian
actors. For their part, expert groups, too, may lack understanding of the
fundamental principles defining and governing humanitarian action, and
may not always make a clear distinction between humanitarian actors and
other actors, such as peacekeeping operations, special political missions, or
human rights actors.
Humanitarian actors carrying out their mandates on the ground sometimes feel constrained by the application of sanctions to the territory in which
they are operating. When the scope of the sanctions is not well understood,
humanitarian actors may “over-comply” with the measures, thereby unnecessarily impeding delivery of humanitarian supplies. Similarly, the requirements
States impose on humanitarian actors as part of national implementation of
sanctions may create difficulties both with respect to perceived neutrality of
the humanitarian actors and in their efforts to obtain necessary funds to carry
out their activities. Standard exemptions for humanitarian actors and their
implementing partners would facilitate their work in conflict areas where
sanctions are applied to resolve conflicts. Humanitarian actors should continue improving their own measures to prevent the diversion of aid.
Humanitarian actors consulted during the Review also reported experiencing difficulties either raising funds for, or transferring funds to, certain
countries subject to UN sanctions. They perceive certain operational difficulties associated with sanctions to be an impediment to their ability to
engage with entities in the field. Some noted confusion about whether the
sanctions prevent them from engaging with such entities, or the degree to
which unintended diversion of funds or material aid to such entities would
place them in breach of the sanctions. They also expressed concern about
how such entities may associate humanitarian actors with the sanctions, thus
restricting humanitarian actors access to communities in need or even placing the humanitarian actors in physical jeopardy.
The degree to which the difficulties noted by humanitarian actors can
be attributed directly to UN sanctions, as opposed to other causes, is unclear.
In all circumstances to which UN sanctions apply, the US and the European Union also apply their own autonomous measures that are significantly
broader in scope than the UN sanctions, and are likely to affect humanitarian actors. There is a need to clarify requirements for such actors as also
discussed in section VI.D, and to understand better the potential impact of
sanctions on important humanitarian activities.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents