84
Compendium: High Level Review of United Nations Sanctions
B. Natural resources
UN sanctions in the form of bans on the importation of certain natural resources are not new. In 1966, an embargo against the exportation
and importation of raw materials from and to Southern Rhodesia was the
first sanctions regime involving natural resources. The Kimberley Process
attempts to stop the trade of conflict diamonds. In connection with the
sanctions on the Democratic Republic of Congo, due diligence obligations
were imposed for all actors involved in the trade of certain minerals originating from the Eastern Congo. In 2014, the Council adopted additional
measures against individuals and entities illegally supporting armed groups
through the illicit trade of wildlife and wildlife products in the Central
African Republic.
Applying sanctions to trade in natural resources requires great care
to avoid unintended consequences. With some exceptions, the targets for
such sanctions are primarily non-state actors and armed opposition groups.
Because the natural resources trade can serve as the main source of revenue
for the affected countries, there is an obvious possibility that legitimate trade
could also be affected. Similarly, the non-state actors who seek to use natural
resource revenues to fund conflict usually rely on artisanal communities
and regional economic structures, often through coercion, to access and
sell the resources. There is therefore a risk that sanctions targeting the sector
could “double victimise” these communities. Sanctions regimes targeting
the exploitation of natural resources should be made adaptable and flexible.
On the other hand, the trend of evolving sophistication of sanctions
strategies in the illicit trade in natural resources and wildlife has shown the
potential to catalyse reform and improve responsible business practices of
all stakeholders involved in affected countries and regions. Properly applied
sanctions may therefore strengthen the national economic position of the
country in question, by ensuring its natural resources are preserved for the
development of the national economy, and not used as a source of conflict and instability. By requiring strengthened governance arrangements for
natural resources, the sanctions can also prevent natural resources becoming
themselves a source of conflict.
137. The Security Council should make better use of existing mechanisms (e.g.
listing criteria, due diligence guidelines and panel of expert reporting)
to address linkages between natural resource management, private sector
actors, financing of targeted entities, and armed conflict.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents