Chapter 4 Ransomware risk to national security | CSAN 2021
4 Ransomware risk to
national security
Ransomware - the criminal act of encrypting files and systems in order to demand a ransom for making them
accessible again - has evolved in such a way that it poses a risk to the national security of the Netherlands.III In
previous editions of the CSAN, the NCTV and the NCSC had already identified ransomware as a phenomenon
that can have a major impact on society. It also has a solid revenue model and is part of an extensive, mature,
cybercriminal economy. Tracking down and prosecuting the perpetrators behind ransomware is therefore not
enough: increasing resilience and disrupting the revenue model deserve just as much attention. In this chapter,
the Police describe the phenomenon of ransomware at perpetrator level, based on observations made by
investigators and supplemented by open sources. The result is a picture of the current nature and scale of
ransomware, the cybercriminal ecosystem of which it is a part and the threat it poses.
The cybercriminal ecosystem
Your files have been encrypted! To decrypt the files, follow the following
instructions...’ Behind this dreaded message is much more than the
cybercriminal sending it. Often, the deployment of ransomware is
the most visible (and painful) step in a much larger process in
which many criminal actors and activities combine to form a
complex whole.
A mature cybercriminal economy
The main motivation of cybercriminals is financial gain. This is
underlined by the fact that this form of crime cannot be separated
from a large underground service economy. Specialisation and
diversification play an important role here: almost every step for
both committing and protecting cybercrime is offered as a service.
The cybercriminal ecosystem can therefore increasingly be
characterised as a mature, global economic sector where supply
and demand come together in cybercriminal forums, among
others, and where rational economic trade-offs are made between
investment, risk and return. This service makes cybercrime
accessible to a wide range of perpetrators. ICT (and its outsourcing)
has a significant amplifying effect here: with minimal effort and
resources, a perpetrator can carry out a large number of criminal
acts worldwide and thus achieve maximum effect. This form of
scalability is what distinguishes cybercrime from other forms of
crime.
Cybercrime is also highly transnational. Perpetrators, service
providers, victims and used or misused infrastructures can be
located all over the world, which poses challenges in terms of
detection, prosecution and the fight against it. The Netherlands
stands out as a country where an above-average amount of
cybercriminal infrastructure is hosted. This is evident from
numerous investigations and foreign requests for mutual legal
assistance.
The extent to which and the way in which perpetrators make use of
cybercrime services varies from one category of perpetrator to
another. Three perpetrator categories can be distinguished:
cybercriminal service providers, dependent perpetrators and
autonomous groups. This rough classification does not alter the
fact that these categories may overlap.
Cybercriminal service providers
These service providers offer Cybercrime-as-a-Service (CaaS). They
offer their products and services primarily on underground, online
platforms such as closed cybercriminal forums, but also on so-
III
Ransomware can also be used by state actors with the aim of causing damage to
and failure of processes (examples are WannaCry and NotPetya from 2017). This
chapter focuses specifically on the use of ransomware by criminal actors and the
risks it poses to national security.
27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents