NCTV | Cyber Security Assessment Netherlands 2021
Damage as a blind spot
Ransomware and national security
The total economic damage of ransomware, in terms of ransom
paid, loss of business continuity, consequential losses and recovery
costs of all attacks added together, is difficult to determine.
Estimates of the global damage run into billions of euros annually,
with a sharp increase in recent years due to an increase in both
RaaS and Big Game Hunting attacks. The cost of damage to the
Netherlands is not known. This blind spot has several causes. In
addition to the highly transnational nature of cybercrime, which
makes it complicated to gain an impression of the damage to the
Netherlands, the willingness of victims of cybercrime to report and
notify is structurally low.
Ransomware attacks pose a risk to national security when it comes
to the continuity of critical processes, the leaking and/or
publication of confidential or sensitive information and
impairment of the integrity of cyberspace; elements that are
mentioned in the Integrated Risk Analysis for National Security and
the Threat Assessment for State Actors. This is especially true of the
threat posed by thorough, combined attacks in the Big Game
Hunting category. National security is at stake when the target of
such an attack is part of the critical national infrastructure
(including the central government and all identified critical
processes) and the attack disrupts the continuity of critical
processes. A ransomware attack can, for example, affect the office
automation of such an organisation. If access to the process
automation is via the office automation, this enables the attacker
to also reach the critical processes to install ransomware there.
However, several indicators show that the economic damage of
ransomware will be considerable for the Netherlands too.
According to the company Coveware, the estimated average
ransom demand peaked at around EUR 200,000 in the third
quarter of 2020. This is the average across all attacks worldwide:
both RaaS attacks where the demand may be a few thousand euros,
and Big Game Hunting attacks where the demand may be in the
millions. In 2020, a record amount of 25 million euros may even
have been demanded in the US or Europe. According to some
estimates, in around 70% of all ransomware attacks, ransoms are
paid by the victim, although the Police cannot verify this figure.
The Police do note, however, that in the Netherlands too, both
demanded and paid amounts are now running into millions of
euros.
However, the total cost of overcoming a ransomware attack is often
higher than the amount of ransom demanded. The Not-Petya
ransomware attack in 2017 shows how extensive the total damage
of a very thorough attack (in this case by a state actor) can be. For
example, for the logistics company Maersk, which was also hit hard
in Rotterdam, this amounted to more than 200 million euros.
Although targeted ransomware attacks on critical processes have
not yet occurred in the Netherlands, they are already happening
abroad. In the United States, for example, federal government
agencies, the Police and the energy sector have been affected. In
addition, ransomware attacks in both the United States and the
European Union during the coronavirus pandemic severely
hampered hospitals, COVID-19 research institutions and a vaccine
distribution centre.
The combination of ransomware with the publication or resale of
sensitive information stolen during the attack is also becoming
increasingly common in the Netherlands. The attack on the
Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO) in early
2021, where internal documents were published on a leak site set
up especially for this purpose, also shows that this could affect the
position of the Netherlands as an innovation country.
Ransomware attacks on local government authorities, such as the
attack on the municipality of Hof van Twente in December 2020,
are a deliberate attack on the integrity of the government's
cyberspace. This may affect the continuity of government services
and public trust in them.
30
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents