Chapter 7 Risk management instrumental in boosting resilience | CSAN 2021
Testing exposes problems
The ball is in the directors’ court
A pitfall with regard to risk management and cybersecurity is to
have everything perfectly in place on paper but dropping the ball in
practice. It is therefore important to actually test processes and
systems as they run on the shop floor and in the field. These tests
can be based on the scenarios identified earlier. Interim shifts in
the threat assessment and the interests to be protected should not
be forgotten. Testing can be done in many different ways, from a
simple tabletop exercise to an extensive threat-based red teaming
exercise. When choosing the scope and the type of test, it is
important to also adopt a risk-based approach. In a more general
sense, the test plan should be linked to the broader risk
management cycle. The effectiveness of measures needs special
attention. Monitoring whether measures have the intended effect
can reveal whether the costs outweigh the benefits. In addition to
the experiences of experts, insights from (academic) research can
also be taken into account.
Risk management without buy-in from the directors will most
likely fail: CISOs who try to manage security on their own sooner or
later discover that the organisation does not feel ownership of the
problem. It is essential that directors are closely involved in risk
management. They are responsible for identifying the strategic
interests within an organisation and for (mandating) the
acceptance of residual risks. The right bodies must be in place and
appropriate responsibilities must be assigned for this. Line
managers, or the owners of digital processes, can take daily
responsibility for the tactical and operational risks. In addition,
directors themselves need to keep abreast of the most significant
risks. This also applies to political leaders, who need to keep an eye
on cyber risks to national security, in order to be able to make
informed decisions between various and divergent interests.
Risk visibility and control is necessary
Learning from and with each other
Risks manifest themselves differently in different organisations.
This is partly due to differences in resilience, but it is also largely a
characteristic of the risks themselves. A risk will not normally
materialise in all cases. This can make it difficult to see relevant risks
and the effectiveness of measures. To deal with this, it is wise to talk
to other organisations. Knowledge and experience can be
exchanged within the framework of ISACs (Information Sharing and
Analysis Centres), with the chain partners of a critical process, and
in other partnerships. For example, within a private consultation,
organisations can share stories about incidents that have happened
to them. The exchange and even the setting of standards are also
possible. In addition to exchanging knowledge, cooperation can
also include joint exercises to test and improve response capacity.
This helps to find each other quickly and anticipate each other’s
needs when the need is great and there is no time for extensive
consultation. The underlying idea in all of this is not to compete in
the area of security, but rather to cooperate.
Public administrators and leaders of organisations are ultimately
responsible for dealing adequately with cyber risks. Strategic as
well as tactical and operational risks can be secured by means of
targeted control and progress monitoring. Clear reporting lines
should be set up for this purpose. CISOs should report directly to
the board and independent internal and external audits are also
important. Of course, the supervisory board and the regulators play
an important role in this. They have the responsibility to check
whether directors and line managers have an adequate view of
relevant risks and whether they act appropriately on them. This
requires monitoring bodies having a keen eye for pertinent
interests, threats and measures. Insight into the information that is
processed within digital processes is a crucial factor. Organisations
themselves do not always have a view of their own resilience, and
the absence of an organisational structure that maintains a grip on
information also plays a role. The tactical layer can, in addition to
the daily responsibility for money and personnel, also be
responsible for the information that belongs within its own
department (and the risks associated with it). Within the tactical
layer, information owners can be appointed who bear
responsibility, are given the means to do so, and are held
accountable by directors for fulfilling this responsibility.
IInvesting in people is the foundation
Risk management is a specialism. This is why public administrators
and leaders of organisations - and people who have the day-to-day
responsibility for digital processes and the associated risks - cannot
be expected to be experts in this field. Instead, they should ensure
that they have put the right people in the right place by investing in
new recruits and in training current staff. This requires a structured
personnel policy, as well as a training programme anchored in the
organisation. In addition to the experts in the field of cybersecurity
risk management, the rest of the organisation must also have a
minimum knowledge base to be able to properly discuss important
risks to the organisation and how to deal with them. This is mainly
about the how and why of the principles behind risk management
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents