its own domestic processes. As a result of this fragmentation, certain behavior that is
understood as criminal in one country may not necessarily be classified as criminal
in another; accordingly, perpetrators may not necessarily be subject to criminal
punishment largely due to the absence of dual criminality (see section 2 A, above).1 In
instances where criminal sanctions may not be available, civil or administrative measures
may exist for specific types of individual cybercrime acts.2
I. Existing National Cybercriminal Legislation
While various cybercrimes have been discussed in section 2 B, above, this section, following
the same construction, considers how national laws have addressed such concerns by looking
at the following cybercrimes: (A) the unauthorized access to a computer system, or hacking, (B)
illegal acquisition of computer data, (C) illegal interception of computer, (D) illegal access to, and
interfering with, computer data, (E) illegal system interference, (F) misuse of devices, (G) fraud, (H)
forgery, (I) spamming, (J) child pornography and (K) copyright and trademark offenses.
A. Illegal Access
Illegal access to a computer system, is, in many ways, one of the most basic cybercrimes as it
enables subsequent (cyber)criminal behavior (see section 2 B, above). Correspondingly, that
behavior is now widely, though not universally, criminalized. Many countries criminalize hacking
through cyber-specific legislation,3 while others criminalize such acts by way of a general offence.4
Depending on the jurisdiction’s chosen approach, the perpetrator must have a certain “guilty”
mental state, or mens rea, in order to be found culpable of this offense.5 Some states take an
approach that expands this offense beyond unauthorized access to include continued or remained
access to the computer system beyond that initial unauthorized trespass, or, if authorization existed,
then presence beyond the period or purposes for which that authorization was granted. Other
jurisdictions classify “illegal access”—what is often termed as “unauthorized monitoring”6—as
a separate offense under separate provisions. Some national laws make illegal access a criminal
offense only if it is paired with interference to or with that data— for instance, the copying,
blocking, destroying, modifying or deleting of the data7; others criminalize the activity only if such
illegal access is committed in connection with one of the components of illegal data or system
interference. It is considered good practice to avoid adding further elements to the base-level
crime, as doing so might lead to difficulties in distinguishing between other offences (e.g., data
espionage, illegal data or system interference), as well as limiting interoperability.8
Page 159 | Chapter 3 | § A. Substantive Law
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents