Formal international cooperation comes in various forms. The most targeted means are (I) cyberspecific multilateral treaties.5 Globally, more than eighty states have signed and/or ratified one
or more binding cybercrime instruments,6 and many of those states have national cybercrime
legislation.7 More generally, formal yet non-cyber-specific mechanisms for international cooperation
include (II) MLATs and (III) extradition treaties. These instruments set up frameworks for
cooperation, encouraging or requiring states to look more closely at their own domestic legislation.
The value of these instruments goes beyond their formal membership, however; notably, by
providing a benchmark for states not bound to such instruments,8 Including when taken together
with other sources of good practice, these instruments provide important guidance when preparing,
for example, model laws.9
I. Multilateral Treaties on Cybercrime
Five major cybercrime-specific, multilateral treaties exist: (A) the CoE’s Budapest Convention, (B)
the CIS Agreement, (C) the SCO Agreement, (D) the Arab Convention and (E) the AU Convention.
Despite these accomplishments and the fact that approximately eighty countries are party to one
or more of the four major multilateral treaties on cybercrime in force,10 the still-relatively limited
coverage of existing multilateral treaties led the Twelfth UN Congress on Crime Prevention and
Criminal Justice in 2010 to conclude that serious consideration ought to be given to developing
a further convention to combat cybercrime.11 That call prompted a discussion on (F) what lessons
have been learned that could enhance membership in formal international instruments. For State
Parties, binding multilateral instruments on cybercrime, as well as other more general anti-crime
instruments with international cooperation provisions that can be used to combat cybercrime,
provide the basic normative framework for addressing cybercrime.
While treaties are, by and large, a positive, their proliferation can be of an issue. One underlying
purpose of a treaty is to encourage cooperation among its Member States or Contracting Parties
on the subject matter of the treaty. However, the growing number of treaties and international
agreements regarding cyberspace poses challenges to ensuring interoperability of the various
instruments, as well as effective cooperation among countries that may be members of different
instruments and may have different obligations regarding cooperation, especially regarding MLA
(discussed below). A more in-depth comparison of the contents of the various cybercrime treaties
can be found in appendix 9 B.
A. Budapest Convention
The Budapest Convention of 2001 is the foremost international instrument on cybercrime, in part
because it is the only truly “global” instrument, being open to signature by non-CoE Member
Page 196 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents