(which have been particularly influential in Caribbean and African countries) offer valuable guidance
on international or regional standards for dealing with cybercrime.47 Moreover, states having
entered into MLATs tend to adopt domestic law on cybercrime.48 In addition, there are a number of
regional instruments dealing with MLA in the broader criminal context.49
According to UNODC, extra-territorial evidence in cybercrime cases is obtained through traditional
forms of cooperation, with over seventy percent of reporting countries using formal MLA. Within
such formal cooperation, almost sixty percent of requests use bilateral MLATs as the legal basis.
Multilateral MLATs are used in twenty percent of cases. Response times for formal mechanisms
were reported to be of the order of months, for both extradition and MLA requests, a timescale that
presents particular in the cybercrime context, as electronic evidence is typically volatile by nature.50
Initiatives for furthering informal cooperation and for facilitating existing formal cooperation, such
as 24/7 networks, offer important potential for faster response times (see section 5 B, below).51
While MLATs can be formed at a multilateral or bilateral level, unfortunately, over sixty percent
of countries are not party to any multilateral cybercrime instrument, meaning that they have no
international legal obligation to either include specialized cybercrime investigative powers in
national procedural laws, or to carry out specialized investigations in response to cooperation
requests.52 Indeed, UNODC has noted “modes of informal cooperation are possible for around
two-thirds of reporting countries, although few countries have a policy for the use of such
mechanisms.”53
Box 5.1: Korea
Example of Legislation on International Judicial MA in Criminal Matters54
“Art. 5: The scope of mutual assistance shall be as follows: (1) Investigation into the
whereabouts of a person or object; (2) Provision of documents and records; (3) Service of
documents, etc.; (4) Gathering of evidence, seizure, search, and verification; (5) Transfer of
objects, such as evidence; (6) Hearing of statements, and other measures to make any person
testify or cooperate with an investigation in the requesting country.
“Art. 6: Mutual assistance may not be provided in any of the following cases: (1) Where it
might be detrimental to the sovereignty, national security, public peace and order, or public
morals, of the Republic of Korea; (2) Where it is deemed that the criminal might be punished,
or subject to an unfavorable penalty disposition, due to his/her race, nationality, gender,
religion, social status, or the fact that he/she is a member of a specified social organization, or
by the reason that he/she has a different political view; (3) Where it is deemed that the crime
under mutual assistance is of a political nature, or a request for mutual assistance is made
for the purpose of an investigation or trial on another crime of a political nature; (4) Where
the crime under mutual assistance does not constitute a crime, or it is a crime against which
Page 200 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents