laws that allow for domestic authorities to conduct cybercrime investigations (see sections 2 C
and 2 D, above), it is important for legislative measures to allow for foreign electronic evidence
to be admissible in legal proceedings, as long as such evidence is gathered in a way of satisfying
procedural legality. While legislative action will be required, it can be facilitated through informal
arrangements, such as bilateral agreements, but also through the standardization of requesting
procedures.
Developing standardized procedures for making information requests and authentication would
greatly advance international interoperability.95 While such would be especially the case once
formal international instruments and systems have been put in place (see section 5 A, above),
those arrangements might also be reached on a more informal level. Such procedures and
understandings operate by building upon principles such as the flag principle, by which jurisdiction
is somewhat more malleably understood (see section 2 E, above).
Control and possession of data has become an increasingly sensitive issue. For instance, the EU-US
Safe Harbor Framework on transatlantic data flows was invalidated by the CJEU on the grounds
that the scheme “enables [... US] public authorities [to interfere] with the fundamental rights of
persons”.96 The fanfare—even alarm97—with which the decision was received, testifies to the
ever-increasing importance of data—for both commercial and investigatory purposes—; and the
rapidity with which a new EU-US arrangement (the so-called “Privacy Shield”) was crafted98 and
adopted99 reinforces that notion (see sections 4 A, and 4 B, above). In that sense, even attempts by
some states to mandate that data pertaining to its citizens be stored on domestic servers, or made
otherwise made automatically accessible (so-called “data localization”), could be construed by
some to facilitate domestic law enforcement agencies. Moves towards data localization, however,
would likely also multiply information requests, pacing burdens on both sides Additionally, while
challenges to managing cross-border jurisdiction might be mitigated by data localization, the
cross-border nature of cybercrime all but ensures that there will be continued need for cross-border
exchanges.
As with efforts to improve MLA (see section 5 A, above), efforts are underway globally to speedup international electronic investigations, while ensuring that they do not violate human rights.
However, just as with efforts to improve MLA, efforts to speed-yet-constrain, remote cross-border
electronic investigation have not yielded a resolution. For many years, the Council of Europe has
been active in researching and discussing the issue of cross-border evidence collection, in which
there is opportunity for participation by states not having acceded to the Budapest Convention in
these discussion.100
Conclusion
Cybercrime can only be effectively investigated and prosecuted when supported through
international cooperation. Formal means of such cooperation include multilateral treaties on
Page 216 | Chapter 5 | § B. Establishing Informal International Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents