E/CN.15/2014/CRP.1
Undercover operations
Online crimes can be especially suitable for undercover work as – compared to the investigation of offline drug
trafficking or organized crime syndicates – investigators are not required to alter their appearance, to invest months or
even years establishing a cover identity, or even to devote themselves to the undercover investigation permanently.
The most common methods of undercover investigations in ICT-facilitated child abuse and exploitation consist of
law enforcement agents posing as children, virtually entering chat rooms, setting up false websites that purport to display
child sexual abuse material, or joining child sexual abuse material communities purporting to be a child sexual abuse
material consumer. Several factors impact the success of such operations. Just as in the real world, the agents conducting
such cyber-investigations must not only be fluent in the potential child victims’ lingo , such as current slang terms and
common Internet chat terms like TTYL (Talk to you later) or LOL (Laughing out loud), but must also have profound
expertise in how sophisticated targets could trace and verify their identity.
Mechanisms for international cooperation
The 2013 Cybercrime Study noted that use of traditional cooperation predominates for obtaining extra-territorial
evidence in cybercrime cases.300 Formal international cooperation mechanisms such as mutual legal assistance – the
process whereby States formally request judicial assistance from another State in criminal investigations – may often
similarly be used in transnational investigations of ICT-facilitated abuse and exploitation. At the same time, however, the
importance of victim identification and protection, as well as the need for timely information sharing has resulted in the
development of effective cooperation mechanisms at the operational law enforcement, as well as strategic levels.
With regard to volatile computer data and at-risk children, both of which require immediate action by law
enforcement, police often need to attain information or assistance faster than they could via formal channels, such as
mutual legal assistance. Informal direct communication between police officers can provide a valuable supplement to
formal procedures. While waiting for official responses to information requests, police can advise each other on how to
follow up time-sensitive leads. They may also be able to inform each other about cultural norms and local practices, which
may facilitate cross-border investigations.301
The Cybercrime Study reported that, while many countries engage in informal cooperation in cybercrime cases,
the range of investigative actions that can be provided through such channels varies considerably, as well as the existence
of clear policies on its use. One major problem in the context of informal cooperation is the fact that many countries
prohibit the use of evidence obtained through such informal channels in the context of judicial proceedings. Nevertheless,
‘24/7’ networks in particular hold a considerable potential for streamlining informal cooperation and facilitating formal
cooperation; however, they still tend to be used infrequently in the investigation and prosecution of transnational
cybercrime. The Cybercrime Study also concluded that, globally, divergences in the scope of cooperation provisions
contained in multilateral and bilateral instruments, a lack of response time obligation, multiple informal law enforcement
networks and variance in cooperation safeguards represent significant challenges to effective international cooperation
regarding electronic evidence in criminal matters.302
At the strategic level, the formation of multi-agency partnerships has emerged as a common practice for
combating technology-facilitated crimes against children. Groups like the Virtual Global Task Force (VGT), the Financial
Coalition against Child Pornography (FCACP), and the International Association of Internet Hotlines (INHOPE) bring
together different agencies from multiple countries to work on specific child exploitation issues. Such initiatives aim to
harness the ideas and resources of multiple entities, resulting in more robust policy and program initiatives.303 Forums for
information-sharing and joint problem-solving are also examples of commonly adopted practices for combating online
child abuse and exploitation.
Working groups sponsored by private entities, individual States, and regional and international coalitions
constitute important opportunities for detailed technical information exchange. The INTERPOL Specialist Group on
__________________
300
301
302
303
UNODC, 2013. P. 197.
UNODC, 2013. Pp. 208-215.
UNODC, 2013. Pp. 197-215,
See, for example, http://www.inhope.org/gns/internet-concerns/overview-of-the-problem/illegal-content.aspx;
http://www.virtualglobaltaskforce.com/what-we-do/.
V.14-03040
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents