E/CN.15/2014/CRP.1
because industry bears the cost of regulation it has incentives to keep enforcement and
compliance costs down.308
Self-regulation may not always, however, be a complete solution in itself when it comes to the prevention of ICTfacilitated child abuse and exploitation. Not all social media sites, for example, necessarily monitor user contents nor
strictly enforce rules regarding user minimum age.
ISP regulation and opportunities for self-regulation
As the ‘gatekeepers’ to the Internet, ISPs around the world face ever-increasing pressure to implement reporting
requirements and mechanisms, or at least codes of conduct, concerning Internet content and acceptable use. Government
policies on the matter vary significantly.309 In the United States and Australia, for instance, ISPs and domain hosts are
required to report any identified child sexual abuse material sites to the police within a reasonable period of time, with
non-compliance being a punishable offence. Similarly, in South Africa, ISPs must take affirmative measures to prevent
their services from facilitating the sharing of child sexual abuse material. ISPs are additionally obliged to reveal any
offending user’s name and IP address to law enforcement authorities.
From the industry perspective, some ISP-associations have drafted formal codes of conduct that require members
to refrain from knowingly accepting illegal content on their sites, and to expediently remove content when they are alerted
to its existence. Larger ISPs may also install dedicated “cyber-patrols” that search for illegal sites. Site hosting providers
may place responsibility for monitoring content on users by relying on them to abide by their terms of service, or may
actively monitor hosted material. Others provide hotlines for users to report suspicious content.310 Website operators
themselves may attempt to render their sites or parts thereof inaccessible to children, by employing techniques for the
identification of a user’s age, ranging from self-certification, to requiring credit card numbers to get past a “pay wall” to
access any adult material contained on the site. This method of screening can be successful, though many teens have
access to credit card numbers and thus can bypass such barriers.
With respect to child sexual abuse material, law enforcement agencies have collaborated with ISPs to use a set of
layered warning mechanisms to deter curiosity-driven, novice child sexual abuse material-consumers. Specifically, they
have developed a series of splash pages that are displayed when suspicious search terms are entered into search engines,
that become more severe the more suspicious the search is. The hope is that these warnings will deter people from
experimenting with child sexual abuse material and contact abuse conduct.
Blocking access to child sexual abuse material URLs is another form of ISP self-regulation. Using a list of illegal
content, ISPs are able to compare content requested by Internet users and block offending materials. Sophisticated
software tools can enable ISPs to more effectively block materials, including material accessed through peer2peer file
sharing programs, where such communications are carried by the ISP. The European Commission has developed a
blocking mechanism for ISPs called the Child Sexual Abuse Anti-Distribution Filter, which is currently used by ISPs in
Denmark, Finland, Italy, Malta, Norway and Sweden.311
A further example of a blocking program is INTERPOL’s “worst of” list of child sexual abuse material materials.
Focused on eradicating the very worst child sexual abuse material on the Internet, INTERPOL coordinates the compilation
of a list of the worst child sexual abuse material on the web. The INTERPOL “worst of” list (now called the IWOL) of
domains is produced by the same countries that already produce lists according to their national legislation. Domains with
very severe child sexual abuse material are seized and shared and re-checked by at least two different child sexual abuse
material specialist police forces or countries before being entered onto the IWOL, which is then distributed to all
INTERPOL countries and available for free to ISPs/service providers. The ISPs/service providers can sign an agreement
with their local INTERPOL office and use the list in all countries where they conduct business. The list can be
automatically downloaded from an INTERPOL server in Lyon, France. The criteria to be added to the INTERPOL list is
__________________
308
309
310
311
Ang, P. H., 2001. The Role of Self-Regulation of Privacy and the Internet. Journal of Interactive Advertising 1:1-9.
A/HRC/12/23. Paragraphs 61-65; see also generally McIntyre, T. J. Child Abuse Images and Cleanfeeds: Assessing Internet
Blocking Systems. Available at
http://www.academia.edu/771272/Child_Abuse_Images_and_Cleanfeeds_Assessing_Internet_Blocking_Systems.
McIntyre, T.J., 2011.
Ibid. P. 7-10.
V.14-03040
49
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents