A/76/136
international obligations of States, including those stemming from international
treaties as the main sources of international law, are applicable in information space.
At the same time, given the specific legal nature of the information environment,
notably, the fact that activities therein can be anonymous, the application of
international law to the use of information and communications technologies (ICTs)
should not be automatic and should not be carried out by simple extrapolation. There
is a need to substantively discuss the issue of how specific instruments of the existing
international law apply to the ICT-sphere, as well as to elaborate a universal approach
to this matter under the UN auspices.
The possibility of attributing responsibility for particular actions in information
space to States demands further study on the basis of the existing international law.
The international responsibility of a State is conditioned to the commission of an
internationally wrongful act by this State. According to the Articles on Responsibility
of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (elaborated by the UN International Law
Commission in 2001, taken note in the UNGA resolution A/RES/56/83), there is an
internationally wrongful act of a State when conduct consisting of an action or
omission: 1) is attributable to the State under international law; 2) constitutes a breach
of an international legal obligation of the State. The characterization of an act of a
State as internationally wrongful is governed by international law. Such
characterization is not affected by the characterization of the same act as lawful by
internal law (article 3).
The countermeasures, which can be taken by an injured State against a State
which is responsible for an internationally wrongful act, shall not affect the obligation
to refrain from the threat or use of force as embodied in the Charter of the United
Nations; obligations for the protection of fundamental human rights; obligations of a
humanitarian character prohibiting reprisals; other obligations under peremptory
norms of general international law (article 50).
Under customary international law, a State is responsible for activities of its
institutions, as well as that of individuals acting under its control. In information
space it may be difficult to determine whether an individual is acting under control of
a State or with its acquiescence. In this regard, it becomes increasingly relevant to
formalize the norm of the 2015 GGE report stating that all accusations of organizing
and implementing wrongful acts brought against States should be substantiated, as
legally binding. In any case, one should refrain from publicly imposing responsibility
for an incident in information space on a particular State without supplying necessary
technical evidence.
Promoting the use of ICTs for peaceful purposes and conflict prevention in this
sphere correspond to the interests of all States. These basic principles of State
activities in information space are enshrined in the abovementioned 2013 and 2015
GGE reports and 2021 OEWG report, as well as in the General Assembly resolutions
adopted by the majority of the UN Member States (namely, A/RES/73/27,
A/RES/73/266, A/RES/74/29, A/RES/75/32, A/RES/75/240 and others).
Readiness and political will of States to undertake relevant legal obligations and
comply with them are required to ensure effective international legal regulation of the
ICT-sphere. In this regard, Russia advocates a broader idea of progressive
development and improvement of international law taking into account the specific
features of ICTs. Given the cross-border nature of interstate legal relationship in this
domain, its legal regulation should be carried out by means of developing and
adopting a binding universal convention on international information security at the
UN level.
80/142
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents