companies, social media and photo sharing businesses and
other third-party providers. Ordinarily, third parties delete
data after a certain period in order to clear server space for
further use.349 The Cybercrime Study noted that the interplay
between law enforcement and service providers is particularly complex. National legal obligations and private sector
data retention and disclosure polices vary widely by country,
industry and type of data. Service providers most commonly
require due legal process for disclosure of customer data.
Accordingly, in many jurisdictions, a court order must be
obtained in order to access electronic evidence from service
providers. In some cases, law enforcement may be able to
obtain data directly, especially where this is facilitated by
informal partnerships between law enforcement authorities
and service providers.
As an increasing number of crimes, including forms of
child abuse and exploitation, involve digital evidence held by
third parties, it is critical that industry and governments work
together to develop mechanisms for timely law enforcement
access to data in emergency situations, combined with fair
and transparent legal processes for routine investigations.
Establishing the means to conduct undercover
investigations
ICT-facilitated abuse and exploitation offences commonly
require undercover operations. Accordingly, first and foremost, States need a clear legal framework for undercover or
covert operations that takes full account of human rights and
rule of law standards.350 Many offenders may require their victims or co-perpetrators to engage in initiation rites, such as
the upload of child sexual abuse material, in order to dissuade
undercover law enforcement agents. Policies and laws must
exist that clearly set out protections and liabilities for law
enforcement officers who encounter such situations.
Undercover operations are most useful where States have
clear criminalization provisions for inchoate crimes, such as
attempts or preparation for an offence. In the absence of such
legal provisions, investigators cannot arrest would-be offenders until and unless the crime is completed, such as when the
victim is actually abused or exploited. This situation, in turn,
considerably undermines the purpose of anti-child abuse and
exploitation laws, policies and operations.351
Increasing awareness and knowledge of
the issues
Non-governmental organizations and members of civil society face the challenge of building upon the public’s general,
although sometimes vague, perception of and awareness of
the risks that have been created by ICTs in the context of
child sexual abuse and exploitation. Particularly in regions of
the world that have limited and only fairly recent access to
ICTs and are not yet sufficiently familiar with the associated
risks and hazards, parents and guardians often lack the specific awareness and skills to protect their children. Even where
broad and relatively sophisticated awareness has been built,
NGOs and members of civil society must continue to raise
awareness on and highlight specific risks and appropriate
counter-measures. 352
Contemporary awareness programmes are likely to have
to undertake concerted efforts to overcome both saturation
regarding digital safety warnings, as well as false confidence
on the part of children and parents about how up-to-date
their level of online safety knowledge is. One emerging idea
in the field of awareness-raising is the concept of “digital citizenship”, which relates to the norms of appropriate, responsible technology use and addresses the topics of digital access,
commerce, communication, literacy, etiquette, law, rights and
responsibilities, health and wellness and security.353
Addressing research gaps
The research community faces the considerable challenge of
filling in the many gaps that exist and continue to emerge in
knowledge on ICT-related child sexual abuse and exploitation. These include up-to-date victimological studies regarding which children may be most susceptible to harm, research
on victimology and perpetrator-profiles with regard to the
developing world, as well as the trend towards increasing levels of violence and increasingly younger victims depicted in
child sexual abuse material.
Wei, W., 2010. Online Child Sexual Abuse Content: The
Development of a Comprehensive, Transferable International Internet
Notice and Takedown System. Available at https://www.iwf.org.uk/
assets/media/resources/IWF%20Research%20Report_%20
Development%20of%20an%20international%20Internet%20
notice%20and%20takedown%20system.pdf.
352
UNICEF, 2011. Pp. 7-9, 21.
353
https://www.iste.org/;http://www.digitalcitizenship.net/
351
For a review of typical data retention times, see UNODC.
2013. P.147-148.
350
Bose, A., 2013.
349
III.
Combating the problem 57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents