A/76/136
5.
Neutrality
As a matter of principle, Switzerland considers the rights and obligations of
neutral countries in international armed conflicts to be applicable to cyberspace as
well. 225 If such an international armed conflict arises, a neutral country has a duty to
prevent any infringements of its neutrality, such as the use of its territory by one of
the conflicting parties. Parties to the conflict are obliged in turn to respect the
territorial integrity of the neutral country. Therefore they may not conduct related
cyber operations from installations that are either on the territory or under the
exclusive control of the neutral country. 226 Parties to the conflict are also prohibited
from taking control of a neutral country’s computer systems in order to carry out such
operations. 227
Because of the global cross border nature of cyberspace, there are also limits to
the rights and duties of a neutral country in terms of territoriality – airspace can be
closed for certain flying objects, for example, but the same targeted approach cannot
be used for data traffic on the internet. Another issue is that data are not only
transmitted via terrestrial and cable channels but also via satellites located in outer
space, which puts them outside the scope of application of the law of neutrality. Such
factors must be taken into consideration when it comes to applying the rights and
duties of neutral countries in cyberspace.
In principle, belligerent states are not permitted to damage the data networks of
neutral countries when undertaking combat operations via their own computer
networks. Neutral countries may not support conflicting parties with either troops or
their own weapons. In terms of military cyber operations in connection with an
international armed conflict, this means that a neutral country must prevent parties to
the conflict from using its military-controlled systems or networks. In general,
military networks are shielded and not publicly accessible.
6.
State responsibility
The customary international rules on state responsibility are largely reflected in the
draft articles issued by International Law Commission. 228 They are also applicable to
cyber incidents. They provide that any state action in violation of international law
shall entail the international responsibility of that state, upon which a claim for full
reparation may be made. This only applies if the action can be legally attributed to
the state and is deemed to constitute an internationally wrongful act, i.e. in violation
of international law.
6.1. Attribution
Attribution of a cybersecurity incident refers to the identification of the
perpetrator and describes a holistic, interdisciplinary process. This includes analysing
__________________
225
226
227
228
21-09670
“The Court finds that as in the case of the principles of humanitarian law applicable in armed
conflict, international law leaves no doubt that the principle of neutrality, whatever its content,
which is of a fundamental character similar to that of the humanitarian principles and rules, is
applicable (subject to the relevant provisions of the United Nations Charter), to an international
armed conflict, whatever type of weapons might be used.” Advisory Opinion on the Legality of
the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, ICJ Reports 1996, para 89.
Art. 2 and Art. 3 Convention Respecting the Rights and Duties of Neutral Powers and Persons in
Case of War on Land (Hague V), 18 October 1907, SR 0.515.21; Art. 2 and Art. 5 Convention
Concerning the Rights and Duties of Neutral Powers in Naval War (Hague XIII), 18 October
1907, SR 0.515.22.
Art. 1 Convention Respecting the Rights and Duties of Neutral Powers and Persons in Case of
War on Land (Hague V), 18 October 1907, SR 0.515.21.
ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, August
2001.
89/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents