2.
o
Broad understanding on the application of international law in cyberspace;
o
Greater understanding on the technical capacities for attribution of responsibility for
cyberattacks;
o
Achieve consensus with regard to the institutionalisation of a regular dialogue in the
framework of OEWG and GGE.
Specific comments on the different sections of the document
Section A “Introduction”:
o Para. 9: We particularly support the recognition that narrowing the digital gap
is an urgent priority for the international community and that should be
mainstreamed through the all the chapters of the group´s agenda.
o Para. 13: This paragraph states that sections B-G “reflect the substantive
discussions of the OEWG and its recommendations”. Hence, it would be
important to clarify the scope of section H and distinguish which of the paragraphs
from section B-G are descriptive and which are prescriptive or contain
recommendations.
Section B “Real and potential Threats”:
o Para. 16: We strongly support the notion that the lack of capacity is a threat in
itself.
Section C “International Law”:
o Para. 20: We share the emphasis on the notion that solutions will be more
effective and long-lasting if they are inclusive and all the actors of the international
community contribute to them.
o Para. 27: We consider that for clarity it would be better to divide this paragraph
into two independent paragraphs. This is due to the fact that as it stands now it
refers to a variety of questions related to the application of international law that
deserve a differentiated treatment. It is proposed that a first paragraph refers to
the clarifications that are needed as regards to what kind of ICT-related activity
might be interpreted by other States as a threat or use of force (Art. 2(4) of the
Charter) or might give a State cause to invoke its inherent right to self-defence
(Art. 51 of the Charter). It is also understood that these are the questions that
should be addressed with prudence.
A second and separate paragraph should refer to the additional clarifications that
may be required on the application of Humanitarian International Law principles
to cyberoperations in the context of armed conflicts.
o Para 32: We strongly support the notion that it is necessary to work towards
developing common approaches regarding attribution at a technical level, which
would contribute to transparency, accountability and responsible behaviour,
enhance deterrence and could provide grounds for legal action by victims of
malicious cyber activities.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents