4
Fields of action
Based on the environment described above and the aforementioned Swiss interests and values in the digital space, it is
possible to envisage various fields of action for Switzerland's
digital foreign policy. To implement them requires action on the
part of all departments as well as increased interdepartmental
cooperation. It is necessary to combine both technical and
political considerations, minimise risks and take advantage of
opportunities, build on existing strengths and pursue foreign
policy initiatives as targeted priorities. As described in the
Foreign Policy Strategy 2020-23, coherence will play a major
part in this.
The following fields of action form the centre of Switzerland's
digital foreign policy for the current legislative period:
4.1 Digital governance
A global phenomenon such as digitalisation requires an
international set of rules, comprising both legally binding
and non-binding instruments. Legally binding instruments
include international treaties and customary international
law. Examples of non-binding instruments are soft law best
practices, technical standards and benchmarks.
international law could undermine the principle under which
currently applicable international law applies in its entirety to
the digital space. The idea of a Digital Geneva Convention
has therefore yet to receive adequate support either from
governments or from the scientific community, business or
civil society.
Globally interconnected to a high degree and with limited
power-political opportunities, Switzerland
is dependent
on international law. With regard to its external economic
interests too, it relies on there being legal certainty and a level
playing field in the digital space so as to allow free competition to flourish."® At a global level, there is general agreement
that the rules enshrined in international law also apply in the
digital space, in the same way as for trade, the preservation
of international security and the protection of human rights.
This means that there is no need to completely overhaul the
international set of rules: it is more a case of substantiating
the existing standards, harmonising them with each other and
continuing to develop them. International governance struc
tures are essential in this regard so that all key stakeholders
are involved in shaping the international set of rules and the
cooperation mechanisms.
In developing the rules and standards, there are a number
of challenges. In recent years, a polarisation has become
increasingly noticeable within the international community:
there are clear differences of opinion between countries that
advocate a centralised, state-driven understanding of the
digital soace and those in favour of a decentralised model.
At the same time, many of the issues are being discussed in
different forums, meaning they are addressed in thematic silos.
With many newly identified issues where there is potential to
adopt a position, for example Al, numerous ad hoc processes
have been started to develop rules which are not aligned.
There are also questions over the legitimacy of some of these
processes as well as a high risk that rules may contradict each
other." Stakeholders are able to cherry-pick the processes and
solutions that benefit them the most (‘forum shopping’), which
exacerbates this trend towards fragmentation. For Switzerland,
it is important that there are processes and structures in place
that enable as many countries as possible to make a substantial
contribution in this area. This is a fundamental requirement for
finding a fair and legitimate solution that is accepted over the
long term.
The Federal Council is sceptical of any single all-encompassing
and legally binding instrument to regulate the digital space,
as is proposed in the postulate. Given the wider international
context, it is unlikely that a binding international agreement on
cybersecurity will materialise in the foreseeable future. Specifically, western nations fear that any new instrument under
10
Inthe area of international
business and commercial
law, Switzerland
in various forums to further develop the legal framework with
the challenges of digitalisation. See ‘Digitalisation and foreign
featured topic of the Federal Council's 2019 Foreign Economic
published 15 January 2020, SR 20.008 (executive summary and
available in English).
8
Fields of action
works
regard to
trade’,
Policy Report,
featured topic
11.
In 2020, the UN identified approximately 160 different ethical Al policies in
organisations and in countries around the world..
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents