Annex 4: International rules
and standards
The existing international rules and
standards for the digital space
International rules and standards for the digital space
already exist. They comprise various instruments, many of
which were established before digitalisation. Others have
been developed more recently specifically for issues related
to the digital space. They can be split into five levels:
>
>
ture.
This five-level body of international rules and standards
for the digital space can be illustrated as follows:
General international law
Atthe highest level are the provisions of general international law. These include customary international law
(e.g. the rules on state jurisdiction such as the territorial
principle). They also include the major multilateral treaties
(e.g. the UN charter, WTO agreements on trade in goods
and services, human rights treaties or — in the case of
Specific international agreements in a given area
Decrees adopted by states or organisations with de facto
international relevance
Soft law
Best practices, benchmarking, technical standards
armed conflicts — international humanitarian law). Finally,
they also include general legal principles (e.g. good faith).
All these general provisions of international law also apply
in the digital space.
>
In addition to these general provisions, there are also
numerous specific international agreements. On the
one hand there are a large number of treaties and agreements which were drawn up before digitalisation, but
which are relevant to the digital space. Bilateral mutual
legal assistance treaties are one example. Among other
things, they regulate the conditions and procedures by
which Swiss prosecution authorities can access evidence
obtained abroad. In principle, this also applies to digital
data. On the other hand, there are agreements which
deal with a specific aspect of the digital space. One example is Convention 108 of the Council of Europe for the
Protection of Individuals with regard to Automatic Processing of Personal Data.
>
Decrees adopted by states and organisations can also
have international significance in the digital space, e.g.
the US CLOUD Act and the EU’s General Data Protec
tion Regulation. While they are not applicable de jure for
States like Switzerland, they may have de facto relevance.
>
Soft law instruments also already exist, mainly established for issues specifically relating to the digital space.
One example are the reports of the UN Governmental
Group of Experts, which adopted a set of non-legally-binding guidelines to promote responsible state behaviour in the digital space.
In terms of best practices, benchmarking and technical standards, there are many instruments that generally contain specific legally non-binding regulations for
the digital space. One example would be ISO standards,
which set standards for the necessary digital infrastruc
Challenges in the application
of these rules and standards
There are three key challenges in the application
existing international rules and standards:
>
of the
The first challenge is the application of international
law provisions that were established before digitalisation to the digital space. This applies to both
general provisions and to specific agreements. For example, there are no clear territorial boundaries in the digital
space. Application of the territorial principle is therefore
a challenge, as several territories may be affected by a
behaviour in the digital soace and various states could
thus claim regulatory authority. At the same time, it must
be possible to separate state competences in the digital
space. In the context of mutual legal assistance treaties,
it is often unclear whether the location where the data is
stored is relevant, or the location where the technology
company holding the data is incorporated. The customary contractually-agreed points of contact and processes
for accessing evidence obtained abroad may face limitations in this respect. Clarification is thus often needed
regarding how the provisions of customary international
law should be applied under the special conditions of the
digital space.
Annex 4: International rules and standards
25
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents