10
property or disruption in the functioning of critical infrastructure, or human injury and loss of
life.
Furthermore, a State may not carry out attacks against targets located within the territory of a
non-belligerent State without the express consent of the latter, unless otherwise allowed by jus
ad bellum rules for the purposes of self-defence or under the authorization of the UN Security
Council. Finally, the law of neutrality must also be taken into account as a possible limit in
international armed conflicts.
d) Cyber operations and the law of neutrality
The law of neutrality applies in cyberspace in the context of an international armed conflict on
the basis of existing international customary law14. According to the law of neutrality, parties
to an international armed conflict may not launch wrongful cyber operations from ICT
infrastructure located in the territory or under the exclusive control of a neutral State.
Within an armed conflict, any action taken by a neutral State should be applied equally to all
belligerents. For instance, a State may not provide or deny access to its ICT infrastructure to
one party but not to the other(s). In addition, neutral States must abide by the rules and
recommendations taken by the UNSC. They may thus not invoke their neutrality to refrain from
adopting such measures against the wrongdoer(s).
IV.
Human rights in cyberspace
Italy finds that international human rights law applies in cyberspace in the same way as it
applies to the analogue world. In particular, each State is bound to protect human rights both
on-line and off-line, protecting individuals from possible violations of those rights, including
but not limited to freedom of opinion and expression, the right to access to information, and the
right to privacy.
14
International Conferences (The Hague), Hague Convention (V) Respecting the Rights and Duties of Neutral Powers
and Persons in Case of War on Land, 18 October 1907; The Hague Convention XIII of 1907 Concerning the Rights and
Duties of Neutral Powers in Naval War. Washington, D.C., The Endowment.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents