CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS Figure 3.10: Cross‐national instruments used to draft or develop planned or existing national cybercrime legislation Existing legislation New or planned legislation Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime (2001) 60% 46% European Union instruments 4% Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children (2007) 73% 52% 16% Additional Protocol to Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime (2003) 15% 12% Other Legislation 15% 12% 12% 12% Commonwealth Model Law Computer Crime/Electronic Evidence (2002) Arab League Model Law (2004) or Arab Convention (2010) 8% ECOWAS Draft Directive on Cybercrime (2009) 8% National legislative models 8% CIS Cooperation Agreement (2001) 12% 12% 15% 4% Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q12 and Q14. (n=26,25; r=51, 50) The complexity of direct implementation of instruments, indirect influence, and their combination, is reflected in aggregate results from the Study questionnaire. During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked which international or regional instruments were used to draft or develop existing and new or planned legislation.112 A comparatively low number of countries responded to the question.113 Figure 3.10 shows, however, that the Council of Europe Convention, its Protocol, and instruments closely based on the Council of Europe Convention, such as European Union instruments, were most widely used for the development of cybercrime legislation. Altogether, multilateral instruments from other international or regional ‘clusters’114 – such as the League of Arab States and African instruments – or other national legislation, were used in around half as many countries. It should be noted that this assessment is based on country responses and not on an examination of the content of national laws.115 This is appropriate insofar as, in general, it is nearly impossible to identify – merely by analysis of legislative provisions – exactly which instruments were used to draft legislation. Only when the approach to the criminalisation of a particular offence suggested by a specific international framework shows some recognisable differences to all of the other instruments, is it possible to ‘trace’ any influence. For example, the Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement116 attaches additional elements to illegal access (effects on data) and criminalizes the distribution of computer viruses in a specific way. Provisions following this 112 113 114 115 116 Ibid. The regional distribution was as follows: regarding existing legislation: Europe 13; Asia & Oceania 7; Americas 5; Africa 5; regarding new or planned legislation: Europe 7; Asia & Oceania 10; Americas 5; Africa 6. See above, Section 3.3 Overview of international and regional instruments. Note that in Chapters Four (Criminalization) and Five (Law enforcement and investigations) of this Study, some results are presented based on primary source legislation analysis. Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 3(1)(a): The illegal accessing of computer information protected by the law, where such act results in the destruction, blocking, modification or copying of information or in the disruption of the functioning of the computer, the computer system or related networks. 75

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents