CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
This Chapter provides a comparative analysis of cybercrime offences found in national
and international law. It demonstrates a certain baseline consensus on the need for
criminalization of a set of cybercrime acts. However, closer examination of offence
elements shows divergence between countries and multilateral cybercrime instruments.
The Chapter also demonstrates the ‘sword and shield’ effect of international human
rights law on cybercrime criminalization.
4.1 Criminalization overview
KEY RESULTS:
Countries report widespread criminalization of the 14 cybercrime acts contained in the Study
questionnaire, with the primary exception of spam offences and, to some extent, offences
concerning computer misuse tools, racism and xenophobia, and online solicitation or ‘grooming’
of children
This reflects a certain baseline consensus on culpable cybercrime conduct
‘Core’ cybercrime acts against the confidentiality, integrity and accessibility of computer systems
are criminalized in many countries using cyber-specific offences
Computer-related acts, such as those involving breach of privacy, fraud or forgery, and identity
offences, are more often criminalized using general offences
80 per cent of countries in Europe report sufficient criminalization of cybercrime acts
In other regions of the world, up to 60 per cent of countries report that criminalization of
cybercrime acts is insufficient
The aim of this Chapter is to provide a comparative analysis of cybercrime offences found
in national law. An understanding of criminalization approaches used, and differences between
national criminal laws in the area of cybercrime, is important for three reasons. Firstly, as discussed,
in Chapter Three (Legislation and frameworks), criminalization gaps in any country can create
offender havens with the potential to affect other countries globally. Secondly, criminalization
differences introduce challenges for effective international cooperation in criminal matters involving
cybercrime – in particular, as regards the principle of dual criminality. Thirdly, a comparative analysis
of cybercrime offences is able to explore good practice that states may use in the development of
national laws, in accordance with emerging international standards in this area. Following a general
overview of cybercrime criminalization, the Chapter examines the specific ways in which states
structure a number of cybercrime offences in national laws. It concludes with a discussion of the
impact of international human rights law on cybercrime criminalization.
77
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents