Cyber-specific and general offences Individual cybercrime acts – such as those identified in Chapter One (Connectivity and cybercrime) – may be addressed by states in a number of ways. Some acts may not be a criminal offence at all in national law. Where acts are a criminal offence, this may be under a general (noncyber-specific law), or a specialized cyber-specific offence. Other acts may not be a criminal offence, but addressed by administrative sanctions, or subject to civil remedies. A number of responding countries indicated that administrative sanctions were used for a range of acts that were not considered a criminal offence, including copyright and trademark offences, sending or controlling sending of spam, acts involving breach of privacy, and the production, distribution or possession of computer misuse tools.1 This Chapter does not examine the use of administrative sanctions or civil remedies, but rather focuses on criminalization. The Chapter begins with an overview of the extent of criminalization of different cybercrime acts, before focusing on the content of national provisions. Figure 4.1 provides a broad overview of the extent of criminalization for the 14 cybercrime act categories, as reported in more than 60 country responses to the Study questionnaire. Responses demonstrate widespread criminalization of the 14 acts, with the primary exception of spam offences and, to some extent, offences concerning computer misuse tools, racism and xenophobia, and online solicitation or ‘grooming’ of children.2 This reflects a certain baseline consensus on culpable cybercrime conduct. As noted in Chapter One (Connectivity and cybercrime), countries reported few additional crimes not mentioned in the questionnaire. These mostly concerned computer content, including criminalization of obscene material, online gambling, and online illicit markets, such as in drugs and persons. The use of criminal law to regulate computer and internet content in particular, is discussed later in this Chapter within the context of the impact of international human rights law on criminalization. Figure 4.1: National approaches to criminalization of cybercrime acts Figure 4.1 also Illegal access shows the clear pattern Illegal interception of use of cyber-specific Illegal interference law for ‘core’ Cyber‐specific Computer misuse tools cybercrime offences offence involving acts against Breach of privacy General offence the confidentiality, Fraud or forgery Both integrity and Identity offences Not an offence accessibility of Copyright or trademark offences computer systems. SPAM Cyber-specific offences Personal harm are less commonly used Racism and xenophobia for other cybercrime Child pornography acts, such as computerrelated acts for personal Solicitation or grooming Terrorism support or financial gain or offences harm, or computer Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q25‐38. (n=61) content-related acts. In contrast, the role of general criminal offences becomes significant for these latter categories. Notably, some countries report using general offences even for core cybercrime acts, such as illegal access to 1 2 Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q25-39. Ibid. 78

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents