Sufficiency of criminal laws for cybercrime In addition to diversity of criminal legislation approach, countries also show differences in perceived ‘sufficiency’ of their cybercrime criminalization frameworks. Around 80 per cent of countries from Europe that responded to the Study questionnaire reported that their criminal laws for cybercrime were sufficient, with the remainder reporting that they were sufficient ‘in part.’ In contrast, in other regions of the world, up to 60 per cent of countries reported that their criminal law frameworks were ‘not sufficient.’ When asked about the Figure 4.2: Sufficiency of national law for criminalization main gaps in cybercrime criminal Europe law, many countries referred (n=20) either to the fact that criminal laws, in general, were not well Asia & Oceania Sufficient (n=19) suited to cybercrime, or to the Sufficient in part Not sufficient absence of offences for particular Americas cyber-conduct. One country in (n=11) Africa, for example, reported that ‘There are no offences of a cyber- or Africa (n=7) information-related nature.’ Another, in Western Asia, referred to the 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q41. (n=57) general problem that ‘The forms and essential elements of natural crime mentioned in the Criminal Code cannot be applied to electronic crimes.’ A country in Southern Asia also noted that ‘We need to have detailed and specific law[s] that should make different aspects of cyber-related acts an offence. Unfortunately, we are waiting for one such law that has not yet been approved.’10 With respect to specific conduct gaps, a country in Western Asia highlighted that ‘There is a legal gap regarding the criminalization of data theft for economic gain.’ A country in the Caribbean noted that ‘There are no specific laws dealing with sending of spam, computer-related acts involving racism and xenophobia, discrimination, cyber bullying and identity theft etc.,’ and a country in South-Eastern Asia highlighted that ‘some specific cybercrimes are currently not criminal offences such as denial of service (DOS) attacks, and spam.’ Many countries reported requiring legislation to deal with highly specific cyber-conduct. One country in Europe, for example, reported that ‘currently [we] do not criminalize botnets, spoofing and grooming.’ Another in South-Eastern Asia noted that ‘currently, online harassment, cyber-stalking, and some identity-related crimes are not adequately addressed.’11 Conversely, countries also reported many strengths and good practices in the criminalization of cybercrime acts. A country in North America, for example, indicated that it was good practice to have ‘Broad coverage of cybercrime acts in technologically neutral language.’ One country in South-Eastern Asia reported that a mixed approach of cyber-specific and general offences was effective, as ‘computer integrity crimes are comprehensively covered by the Computer Misuse Act [and] most other forms of cybercrime are also addressed to a large extent, though by non-cyber specific laws.’ A country in Oceania highlighted a need for ‘wide coverage of acts of cybercrime’ and the importance of deterrence through ‘strong penalties.’12 10 11 12 Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q41. Ibid. Ibid. 80

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents