‘functional’ comparative law.15 For primary source legislation analysis, legislation for each particular
cybercrime act was not available from all countries. Thus, numbers of countries included in this part
of the analysis vary depending upon the cybercrime offence examined.16
Illegal access to a computer system
The act of accessing a computer system
Illegal access: Council of Europe Cybercrime
without proper authorization has existed since the
Convention
early days of the development of information
Article 2 – Illegal Access
technologies.17 Illegal access threatens interests such as
the integrity of computer systems. The legal interest is
Each Party shall adopt such legislative and other
infringed not only when a person without
measures as may be necessary to establish as
criminal offences under its domestic law, when
authorization alters or ‘steals’ data in a computer
committed intentionally, the access to the whole
system belonging to another, but also when a
or any part of a computer system without right. A
Party may require that the offence be committed
perpetrator merely ‘looks around’ in the computer
by infringing security measures, with the intent of
system. The latter infringes upon the confidentiality of
obtaining computer data or other dishonest
the data, and considerable actions on the part of the
intent, or in relation to a computer system that is
connected to another computer system.
victim may be required to check the integrity or status
of the system. ‘Pure’ or ‘mere’ illegal access to a
computer system does not require that the offender accesses system files or other stored data.
Criminalization of illegal access thus represents an important deterrent to many other subsequent
acts against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of computer systems or data, and other
computer-related offences, such as identity theft and computer-related fraud or forgery.18
As a consequence, eleven
multilateral instruments require the
adoption of provisions criminalizing
5%
Yes, cyber‐specific
illegal access to computer systems or
offence
data.19 Legislation on the national level
Yes, general offence
19%
well reflects this requirement. Figure 4.3
Yes, both
shows that about 70 per cent of
responding countries to the Study
No, not a criminal offence
questionnaire reported the existence of
the cyber-specific offence of illegal
69%
access to a computer system.20 In
addition, about 20 per cent of
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q25. (n=59)
responding countries reported that the
act was covered by general provisions of criminal law. Very few countries, only 7 per cent, do not
criminalize illegal access to a computer system at all.
Figure 4.3: Criminalization of illegal access to a computer
system
7%
15
16
17
18
19
20
For details of the methodology of comparative criminal law, see Sieber, U., 2006. Strafrechtsvergleichung im Wandel. In: Sieber, U.,
Albrecht, H.J. Strafrechtsvergleichung und Kriminologie unter einem Dach. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot, pp.78 and 111-130.
A maximum number of 90 countries were analysed (for illegal access provisons), and a minimum number of 70 were analysed (for
child pornography and computer misuse tool provisions).
See Kabay, M., 2009. History of Computer Crime. In: Bosworth, S., Kabay, M.E. and Whyne, E., Computer Security Handbook. 5th ed.
New York: Wiley; Sieber, U., 1986. The International Handbook of Computer Crime. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, pp.86-90.
See Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, ETS No. 185, para. 44: ‘Illegal access covers the
basic offense of dangerous threats to and attacks against the security (i.e., the confidentiality, integrity and availability) of computer systems and data.’
Draft African Union Convention, Arts. III-15, III-16; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Arts. 18, 19; Commonwealth Model Law, Art.
5; Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 2; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 2; EU Decision on Attacks against
Information Systems, Art. 2(1); EU Directive Proposal on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 3; ITU/CARICOM/CTU
Model Legislative Texts, Art. 4; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 6; League of Arab States Model Law, Art. 3, 5, 15, 22;
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 3(1)(a).
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q25.
82
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents