CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION Primary source legislation analysis of illegal access provisions for some 90 countries shows cross-national differences with regard to the object of crime, the acts covered and the mental element. Offence object - All international and regional cybercrime instruments provide for criminalization of illegal access to the whole or part of a computer system. Only around 55 per cent of the countries included in the primary source legislation analysis, however, follow this approach. Figure 4.4 demonstrates that some national laws limit the object of illegal access to data or information instead of a system, or criminalize access to both data and system, sometimes in different provisions. Some national provisions Figure 4.4: Objects of illegal access go even further in limiting the Whole System 8% approach. Several countries in 32% Whole System or part Western Asia and Eastern Europe, Data and System for example, criminalize illegal access 14% Data to ‘information protected by law.’ Information Acts covered – Criminalization of ‘mere’ illegal access, or the requirement for further intent or acts, represents 22% another point of divergence. All 24% international instruments provide for the option of criminalization of mere Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=87) unauthorized access to a computer system. Some instruments, however, allow for further conditions. The Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention21 and the ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts,22 for example, provide countries with the possibility of attaching additional conditions – such as ‘bypassing security’ or ‘dishonest intent’. The EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems gives Member states an opportunity to avoid criminalization of minor cases.23 The Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement requires criminalization of illegal access if it results in ‘destruction, blocking, modification or copying of information or the disruption of the functioning of the computer, the computer system or related networks.’24 Such conditions enable states to adopt narrower legislation on illegal access. Indeed, consensus is not universal on the desirability of criminalization of mere illegal access to non-protected systems.25 On the other hand, some conditions provided by international approaches, especially those that include requirements for additional acts, may lead to challenges in distinguishing illegal access from subsequent offences – with possible confusion of boundaries between illegal access and offences such as data interference or data espionage. 21 22 23 24 25 Illegal access: National example from a country in Southern Europe Whoever, without legal permission or authorization from the owner or holder of the right over the full system, or part thereof, accesses a computer system, shall be punishable by a term of imprisonment up to ___ year or by fine up to ____. Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 2. ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 5. EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 2. Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 3(1)(a). See, for example, Sieber, U., 1985. Informationstechnologie und Strafrechtsreform. Cologne: Carl Heymanns Verlag, p.49. 83

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents