CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
saved data, electronic instruments and systems and communication networks, and damages to the users and
beneficiaries, or to the acquirement of secret government information’ (Art. 6). The COMESA Draft Model Bill
has additional provisions criminalizing illegal access to ‘government computers’ or ‘computer systems used for
critical infrastructure operations’ (Art. 19). The EU Directive Proposal on Attacks against Information
Systems (Art. 10) introduces the requirement of aggravated penalties for crimes of illegal access
committed: (i) within the framework of a ‘criminal organisation’; (ii) through the use of a ‘tool designed to
launch attacks affecting a significant number of information systems’ or attacks causing considerable damage,
such as disrupted system services, financial cost, or loss of personal data; or (iii) by ‘concealing the real
identity’ of the perpetrator and causing prejudice to the rightful identity owner.
At the national level, many countries that criminalize mere illegal access have also created
aggravating circumstances that attract more severe sanctions. Such circumstances vary significantly
from country to country. Those identified include:
Commission of the act with illegal financial or detrimental intent;
Interfering with the functioning of a computer system;
Suppressing or altering data;
Copying, using, disclosing, or any other violation of computer data or programmes;
Accessing a third computer;
Causing considerable damage;
Creating public disorder;
Facilitating or supporting terrorism;
Committing the act as a member of an organized group;
Combining the act with violent behaviour.
As discussed above, many such circumstances present overlap with other possible, separate,
offences, such as illegal data interference or system damage. The most common aggravating
circumstance seen during primary source legislation review, however, was the involvement of
computers critical to the functioning of infrastructure such as banking, telecommunications, health
services, public services or government computers. More than half of the national laws examined
provided special protection by way of increased penalties for illegal access to computers run by state
authorities, or that could be linked to the functioning of critical infrastructure.
Illegal remaining in a computer system
Two multilateral instruments cover not only
‘remaining in’ a system without the right to do
ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts
give countries the possibility of not criminalizing
mere unauthorized remaining in the system,
provided that other effective remedies are available.
The ECOWAS Draft Directive, on the other hand,
requires criminalization of ‘fraudulently’ remaining in
a computer system.
illegal access to a computer system, but also
so after authorisation has expired.30 The
Illegal remaining: ECOWAS Draft Directive
Article 3 – Fraudulently remaining in a
computer system
The act by which a person fraudulently remains or
attempts to remain within the whole or part of a
computer system.
These divergences are reflected in the national legislation. Some laws incorporate the
concept of illegal remaining into illegal access provisions, while others criminalize it separately. More
30
ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 3; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 5.
85
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents