requirement represents a restrictive condition in order to avoid over-criminalization.37 The
limitation, however, is not always reflected in national approaches. Figure 4.8 shows that more than
half of the countries for which legislation was
analysed, in all regions of the world, do not include
Illegal interference: EU Decision on Attacks
against Information Systems
technical means as an element of the illegal
interception offence.
Article 4 – Illegal data interference
Each Member State shall take the necessary
measures to ensure that the intentional deletion,
State of mind – Multilateral instruments usually
damaging, deterioration, alteration, suppression
require that the crime of illegal interception be
or rendering inaccessible of computer data on an
committed intentionally. The Council of Europe
information system is punishable as a criminal
offence when committed without right, at least
Cybercrime Convention, for instance, provides parties
for cases which are not minor.
with the possibility to limit the offence of illegal
Illegal interference: Council of Europe
interception to cases committed with dishonest intent.
Cybercrime Convention:
The review of national legislation showed that very
Article 5 – System interference
few countries require further intent, although some do
Each Party shall adopt such legislative and other
link interception with the intent to commit further
measures as may be necessary to establish as
offences. One country in Eastern Europe, for
criminal offences under its domestic law, when
committed intentionally, the serious hindering
example, criminalizes illegal interception of data only
without right of the functioning of a computer
for the purpose of committing specific computer
system by inputting, transmitting, damaging,
deleting, deteriorating, altering or suppressing
offences. In addition, some countries include
computer data.
additional intent as an aggravating circumstance. Two
countries in Western Europe, for instance, provide
aggravated penalties for unauthorized interception committed with the intent to achieve financial
advantage.
Illegal interference with a computer system or computer data
Interference with computer data or systems endangers the integrity and availability of
computer data, as well as the
proper operation of computer
Figure 4.9 : Criminalization of illegal data interference or system
damage
programmes
and
computer
1%
7%
systems. Due to the non-tangible
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
nature of computer data, many
Yes,
general
offence
national legal systems may not be
22%
able to extend traditional criminal
Yes, both
law provisions dealing with
No, not a criminal offence
destruction of physical property
to interference with computer
Most
multilateral
data.38
70%
instruments therefore include
specific offences concerning
illegal data and/or system
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q27. (n=60)
interference.
At the national level, Figure 4.9 shows that over 90 per cent of responding countries have a
criminal offence covering illegal interference with a computer system or computer data. Seventy per
37
38
Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, ETS No. 185.
Sieber, U., 2008. Mastering complexity in the global cyberspace: The harmonization of computer-related criminal law. In: DelmasMarty, M., Pieth, M. and Sieber, U., (eds.) Les chemins de l’Harmonisation Pénale/Harmonising Criminal Law. Collection de L’UMR de Droit
Comparé de Paris. Vol. 15. Paris: Société de législation comparée.
88
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents