than 50 per cent of countries reported the use of general provisions. Around 10 per cent of
countries reported that identity-related acts do not constitute a criminal offence.
Analysis of primary source legislation shows that, for cyber-specific identity-related
offences, the object of identity theft is usually defined as ‘data’ (or ‘personal data’) or ‘identification
information.’ Where provisions exist, they do not always cover all acts that can constitute the possible
components of identity theft. Some countries do not, for example, include the ‘transfer’ of personal
data, but rather limit criminalization to acts such as ‘using’ and ‘obtaining’ the means of
identification. Others cover only ‘obtaining’, or do not include obtaining or use at all (see example
box from a country in the Caribbean). Some national laws go further and also criminalize creating
false personal data. Overall, a review of primary source legislation suggests that the number of
countries with cyber-specific identity offences is relatively low, and for those that do, significant
divergence in approaches exists. Where identity-related offences are covered by general laws, this
can be through a number of different provisions, including on illegal access, illegal data interference,
computer misuse tools, computer-related forgery and computer-related fraud.
Child pornography offences
Almost all images containing child
pornography are transmitted electronically,
through bilateral and multilateral exchanges.69
Interests protected by the criminalization of child
pornography include the protection of minors
from abuse, and the disruption of markets in child
pornographic images, that may encourage
offenders to seek to produce and supply further
images.70 At the international and regional levels,
nine identified instruments include provisions
criminalizing acts related to child pornography.71
Although international frameworks demonstrate
many similarities with respect to the criminalization
of child pornography, differences also relate to the
object, age of children, and acts covered.
Child pornography: Optional Protocol to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child
Article 3
1. Each State Party shall ensure that, as a
minimum, the following acts and activities are
fully covered under its criminal or penal law,
whether such offences are committed
domestically or transnationally or on an
individual or organized basis: …
(c) Producing, distributing, disseminating,
importing, exporting, offering, selling or
possessing for the above purposes child
pornography as defined in article 2. …
3. Each State Party shall make such offences
punishable by appropriate penalties that take into
account their grave nature.
At the national level, over 80 per cent of countries responding to the Study questionnaire
indicated that child pornography is a criminal offence. The majority of countries reported that such
acts are criminalized by way of a general offence. As acts involving child pornography may be
perpetrated through a wide range of media – including ‘offline’ images – a general ‘technology and
media neutral’ approach is preferred to a computer-specific approach by many countries. A number
of country responses to the Study questionnaire suggested that child pornography was criminalized
within the context of pornography generally. This was confirmed by analysis of source legislation,
during which two countries with general provisions on pornography, including child pornography,
were identified. For countries which do not have specific provisions on child pornography, it is
possible that such material can be prosecuted using broader laws on obscenity or offensive material.
69
70
71
UNODC, 2010. The Globalisation of Crime. A Transnational Organized Crime Threat Assessment. Chapter 10. Available at:
http://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/tocta/10.Cybercrime.pdf, p.212.
See Hamilton, M., 2011-2012. The child pornography crusade and its net-widening effect. Cardozo Law Rev, 33(4):1679-1732.
Draft African Union Convention, Art. III-29 to III-32; Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 10; Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention, Art. 9; Council of Europe Child Protection Convention, Art. 20; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Arts. 14-17; EU
Directive on Child Exploitation, Art. 5; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 13; League of Arab States
Convention, Art. 12; United Nations OP-CRC-SC, Art. 3.
100
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents