CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
Model Law, use the term ‘child’ or ‘minor’ without setting an age limit.
At the national level, identifying the age to which child pornography provisions apply is not
straightforward. Many countries refer to the term ‘minor’ or ‘child’ without specifying an age in the
article itself. Rather, relevant ages may be found in other parts of national legislation – including
child protection or child rights legislation. Figure 4.26 shows that for many of the available criminal
law provisions analysed, it was not possible to easily identify the relevant age (without detailed
analysis of other parts of the national law). Where it was possible to identify the age from national
criminal law, the large majority of provisions referred to the age of 18 years. Criminal laws in only a
few countries contained an age of
16 or 14 years for the purposes of
Figure 4.27: Acts constituting child pornography offences
defining child pornography. In this
respect, the United Nations
Accessing
37%
Committee on the Rights of the
Posession only
63%
Child has expressed particular
concern over the use of age limits
Distribution
93%
of 14 years.77
Copying
14%
Acts covered – The majority
Production
89%
of international and regional
instruments require criminalization
of a wide range of actions
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=70)
associated with child pornography,
including ‘production’, ‘offering’, ‘making available’, ‘distribution’, ‘transmission’, and ‘possession’. Some
instruments also criminalize knowingly ‘obtaining access’ to child pornography.78 National laws show
some diversity with respect to which of these acts are included. As can be seen in figure 4.27,
‘production’ and ‘distribution’ of child pornography are most commonly criminalized – by around 90
per cent of national legislative provisions reviewed. Over 60 per cent of countries reviewed
criminalize ‘possession,’ with almost 40 per cent including provisions on ‘accessing’ child pornography.
In some countries, the extent to which ‘possession’ provisions can be applied in the case of online
viewing of still or moving images remains unclear. A number of countries in Europe include online
viewing of child pornography within the scope of possession due to the fact that viewing pictures
necessarily includes the copying of images into computer memory and/or temporary internet cache
files. Other countries have created solutions such as a requirement for ‘habitual activities’ on the part
of the perpetrator.
Computer-related solicitation or ‘grooming’ of children
Criminal laws on online child ‘grooming’ represent a form of criminalization of acts
preparatory to ‘offline’ abuse of children.79 Two multilateral instruments, both from the European
region – the Council of Europe Child Protection Convention (Art. 23) and the EU Directive on
Child Exploitation (Art. 6) – require criminalization of such acts. The core elements of the offence
include the ‘intentional proposal, through information and communication technologies,’ by an adult to ‘meet’ a
77
78
79
See, for example, CRC/C/OPSC/EST/CO/1 (2010) and CRC/C/OPSC/AUT/CO/1 (2008). The Committee also considers that
the use of offence conditions such as ‘intent to disseminate’ and ‘where the minor does not consent’ for child pornography
offences involving children between 14 and 18 years are incompatible with the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights
of the Child.
Draft African Union Convention; Council of Europe Child Protection Convention; EU Directive on Child Exploitation;
ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts.
Eneman, M., Gillespie, A. A., Bernd, C. S., 2010. Technology and Sexual Abuse: a Critical Review of and Internet Grooming Case.
ICIS 2010 Proceedings. Paper 144; Kool, R., 2011. Prevention by All Means? A Legal Comparison of the Criminalization of Online
Grooming and its Enforcement. Utrecht Law Review, 7(3):46-69.
103
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents