CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
Performances and Phonograms Treaty.82 More recently, the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement
(ACTA) aimed to consolidate criminal provisions on wilful trademark counterfeiting or copyright or
related piracy rights on a commercial scale.83 The European Parliament voted against the Agreement
in 2012. At the European Union level, a number of pieces of legislation deal with aspects of
copyright and related rights, but none of them explicitly include criminal provisions.84 In 2005, the
European Parliament drafted a proposal for a framework decision and a directive on measures
concerning criminal copyright law committed on a commercial scale.85 This directive was revised in
2006 but has not yet been adopted.86
At the national level, developments in the last decade have been characterized by an
increase in sanctions for copyright offences, in particular for cases of commercial and organized
acts. The Council of Europe
Cybercrime Convention, for
Figure 4.29: Criminalization of computer‐related copyright and
example,
provides
for
trademark offences
11%
criminalization of infringement
4%
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
of copyright and related acts
Yes, general offence
14%
where ‘committed wilfully, on a
Yes, both
commercial scale and by means of a
No, not a criminal offence
computer system.’87 At the national
level, responding countries to the
Study cybercrime questionnaire
indicated a high level of
71%
criminalization of copyright and
trademark offences, with over 80
per cent of countries stating that
such acts could be a crime. The
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q32. (n=55)
vast majority of these countries
reported use of general offences rather than cyber-specific offences.
In practice, the large amount of infringing material on the internet (see Chapter Two (The
global picture)) often means that law enforcement resources are not sufficient to prosecute the mass
of possible cases. For this reason, many states also support new concepts involving civil law
measures, such as written warnings, damage claims and the right to information. In addition, some
countries have developed ‘two strikes’ and ‘three strikes’ models. These concepts oblige internet
service providers to register IP addresses of copyright infringers, to send warning notices to firsttime offenders, and to take responsibility for sanctioning of repeat offenders, or to collaborate by
notifying right-holders or authorities.88
Discussion
The above analysis shows both similarities and divergences in national criminalization
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty, signed on 20 December 1996.
See Arts. 23 et seq. of the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA).
Sieber, U., Brüner, F.H., Satzger, H., Von Heintschel-Heinegg, B. (eds.) 2011. Europäisches Strafrecht, pp.442 et seq.
Proposal for a directive on criminal measures aimed at ensuring the enforcement of intellectual property rights and proposal for a
framework decision to strengthen the criminal law framework to combat intellectual property offences from 12 August 2005, COM
(2005)276 final.
Amended proposal for a directive on criminal measures aimed at ensuring the enforcement of intellectual property rights from
26.4.2006, COM (2006) 168 final.
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art.10.
See Bridy, A., 2010. Graduated Response and the Turn to Private Ordering in Online Copyright Enforcement. Oregon Law
Review, 89:81-132; Stamatoudi, I., 2010. Copyright Enforcement and the Internet. Alphen aan den Rijn, Netherlands: Kluwer Law
International; Haber, E., 2011. The French Revolution 2.0: Copyright and the Three Strikes Policy. Harvard Journal of Sports &
Entertainment Law, 2(2):297-339.
105
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents