containing relevant protections.114
Freedom of expression on the internet – Case example
With respect to limitations on
In November 2011, the European Court of Justice (ECJ)
freedom of expression, respondents
ruled that ISPs may not be asked to filter content for
copyright enforcement purposes, as this would infringe the
referred to a wide range of possible
rights of subscribers to privacy, and to freedom of
restrictions. These included generic
expression. According to the Court, an injunction to filter
would not only ‘contravene’ the EU Directive on elimitations found in international human
Commerce, but it would also ‘infring[e] the fundamental rights of
rights law, such as for the protection of
[the] ISP’s customers, namely their right to protection of their personal
‘national security’, ‘public safety and
data and their freedom to receive or impart information…[Firstly], the
injunction requiring installation of the contested filtering system would
prevention of disorder or crime,’ ‘public
involve a systematic analysis of all content and the collection and
order,’ ‘public health,’ and ‘public morals.’
identification of users’ IP addresses from which unlawful content on the
network is sent. Secondly, that injunction could potentially undermine
They also included more specific
freedom of information since that system might not distinguish
limitations,
such
as
‘breach
of
adequately between unlawful content and lawful content, with the result
confidentiality,’
‘legal
privilege,’
that its introduction could lead to the blocking of lawful
communications’.A management company representing creators
‘defamation,’ ‘threats to person or
of musical works in authorising the use of their copyrightproperty,’ ‘inducement to crime,’ ‘material
protected materials by third parties, had sued an ISP which
provides access to the internet without offering other
assistance to terrorism,’ ‘propaganda for
services such as downloading or file sharing. The former had
war,’ ‘incitement to genocide,’ ‘incitement
asked the ISP to monitor and subsequently block P2P
to national, racial or religious hatred,’
transfers of files concerning materials created by European
clients it represented.
‘insults to religious feelings,’ ‘contempt,
slander or defamation of protected
Source: ECJ Case No. C-70/10
religions,’
‘material
jeopardizing
harmonious relations amongst peoples,
castes, tribes and communities,’ ‘obscenity,’ ‘pornography,’ ‘undermining the prestige of the state or
undermining confidence in its financial status,’ and ‘dissemination of official secrets.’115
A number of countries referenced international and regional law as the source of some of
these limitations, including the EU Council Framework Decision on combating racism and
xenophobia,116 and the Protocol to the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention.117 Others
referred only to national laws. Some countries provided information on the way in which the
legitimacy of limitations is determined.118 Most countries, however, did not provide information on
the approach used to determine the legitimacy of restrictions on freedom of expression. Some
countries were clear that specific limitations on freedom of expression arose from criminal
prohibitions. In general, however, respondents did not specify whether limitations were of a
criminal, administrative or civil nature.
Limitations on freedom of expression and international law
Some limitations on freedom of expression cited by respondents enjoy a high degree of
support from international human rights law. At the most extreme, the ‘sword’ function of
international human rights law requires prohibition of certain (limited) forms of expression. The
114
115
116
117
118
Ibid.
Ibid.
EU Council Framework Decision 2008/913/JHA of 28 November 2008 on combating certain forms and expressions of racism
and xenophobia by means of criminal law, OJ L 328 of 6 December 2008.
Articles 3 to 6 of the Protocol to the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention require states parties to adopt such legislative and
other measures as may be necessary to establish as criminal offences the dissemination of racist and xenophobic material through
computer systems, racist and xenophobic motivated threats, racist and xenophobic motivated insults, and denial, gross
minimisation, approval or justification of genocide or crimes against humanity.
One country in Africa, for example, stated that ‘rights in the Bill of Rights may be limited only in terms of law of general application to the extent
that the limitation is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom, taking into account all
relevant factors, including – (a) the nature of the right; (b) the importance of the purpose of the limitation; (c) the nature and extent of the limitation; (d)
the relation between the limitation and its purpose; and (e) less restrictive means to achieve the purpose.’ Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q20.
110
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents