conditions and safeguards than for disclosure of the data, due to an arguably less prejudicial nature
of the preservation measure (before the point of any disclosure). In this respect, however, it should
be noted that international human rights mechanisms have held that mere storage of information
about an individual amounts to an interference with rights to private life.48 Exercise of preservation
orders therefore still requires an assessment of the proportionality of the measure – in particular
where compliance with the order would require specific data to be held for longer than the time
period envisaged by data protection legislation.
Nonetheless, preservation of data represents an important measure for maintaining vital
evidence prior to a full order for disclosure – in particular in the context of transnational
investigations. Indeed, the separation of the two obligations, ‘preservation’ and ‘disclosure’ is a key
element of the measure.49
At the national level – perhaps due to the influence of international and regional cybercrime
instruments – expedited preservation of data is the measure in respect of which the highest
proportion of countries report a cyber-specific power. Nonetheless, country responses also
indicated that general provisions could cover the measure in various ways. One country in Western
Asia, for example, stated that
Figure 5.6: Expedited preservation of computer data
provisions on search and seizure
were interpreted as providing for
expedited preservation.
Another
29%
22%
country in Southern Africa also
Cyber‐specific powers
explained that computer data can be
General powers
preserved according to its legislation
6%
Both
by means of computer seizure, and
one country in Western Europe
Neither
noted that it uses general provisions
41%
on seizure of correspondence and
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q49. (n=49)
other information.50 In addition,
however, over 20 per cent of responding countries indicated that national law did not include a
power to ensure expedited preservation of data. The absence of legal authority for such a
fundamental investigative tool presents a significant challenge – not only for those particular
countries, but also for any other country wishing to seek investigative assistance.
Orders for computer data
As discussed in Chapter One (Connectivity and cybercrime), a large part of the
infrastructure and computer systems used for internet communications are owned and operated by
the private sector. Internet service providers, as well as electronic communication providers and
web-service providers, therefore route, store, and control a significant amount of computer data
related to internet connections, transactions, and content. The use of coercive measures, such as
search and seizure, by law enforcement for obtaining these data are unfeasible in the majority of
circumstances – due both to the volume of individual cases investigated, and disruption to legitimate
business activity. Orders to such third parties to the investigation for computer data thus provide a
due legal process route to obtaining electronic evidence.
48
49
50
See, for example, ECtHR. Application No. 9248/81.
See Brown, I., 2010. Communications Data Retention in an Evolving Internet. International Journal of Law and Information Technology,
19(2):107.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51.
128
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents