such information.
This is supported by comments from
Order for traffic data: National example from
responding countries. One country in the Americas,
a country in Oceania
for example, stated that, although providers often
Disclosure of traffic data
cooperate with law enforcement agencies voluntarily,
Where a magistrate is satisfied on the basis of an
application by any police officer that specified
the application of existing general procedural
data stored in a computer system is reasonably
provisions to orders for supply of data was too
required for the purpose of a criminal
onerous and impractical. The country had therefore
investigation or criminal proceedings, the
magistrate may order that a person in control of
initiated the process of adopting a cyber-specific
the computer system disclose sufficient traffic
provision for subscriber data orders.54 On the other
data about a specified communication to identify:
(a) the service providers; and
hand, a few countries reported successful use of
(b) the path through which the communication
general provisions. One country in South-Eastern
was transmitted
Asia, for instance, highlighted the possibility of
extension of a general investigative power to order
‘any document or other thing.’ One country in South America also reported that the power of a judge to
‘examine sealed correspondence’ had been extended to stored data.55
Aside from the legal form of investigative powers, the interplay between law enforcement
and internet service providers for the obtaining of electronic evidence can be particularly complex.
Later sections of this Chapter examine the use of powers in practice, as well as challenges faced by,
and good practice used by, law enforcement in obtaining data from service providers.
Real-time collection of data
Orders for data represent an investigative measure for obtaining stored computer data.
Crucial electronic evidence may also, however, never be stored at all (existing only in transient
communications),
or
Figure 5.8: Order for real‐time traffic and content data
require
‘real-time’
collection, due to the
urgency, sensitivity, or
Real‐time traffic
data
complexity of a law
(n=50)
enforcement investigation.
Cyber‐specific powers
Accordingly,
six
international or regional
Both
Real‐time content
cybercrime
instruments
data
Neither
(n=51)
include provisions on realtime collection of computer
data.
In
doing
so,
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
instruments typically make
a distinction between realSource: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q47 and Q48. (n=50, 51).
time collection of traffic
56
57
data and of content data. This distinction relates, not least, to differences in the level of
intrusiveness into the private life of persons subject to each of the measures.58 The section on
General powers
54
55
56
57
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51.
COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 38; Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 19; Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 20;
ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 25; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 28.
Draft African Union Convention, Art. 3-55; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 39; Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 18; Council of
Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 21; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art.26; League of Arab States
Convention, Art. 29.
130
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents