about keyboard activity and computer data stored
on, or transmitted or received, by the device.63 Due
to the range of personal information stored on
computer devices, the use of such tools represents
a significant intrusion into the private life of
investigation subjects. From an evidential
perspective, evidence obtained by the use of remote
tools on ‘live’ computer systems may also be open
to challenge. It must be demonstrated, for example,
that the operations performed by the examiner did
not themselves alter the state of the system under
investigation.64
Remote forensic software: National example
from a country in Oceania
Remote access search of thing authorized by
warrant
Every person executing a search warrant
authorising a remote access search may—
(a) use reasonable measures to gain access to
the thing to be searched; and
(b) if any intangible material in the thing is
the subject of the search or may
otherwise be lawfully seized, copy that
material (including by means of
previewing, cloning, or other forensic
methods).
Only one (non-binding) international or
regional instrument refers to the use of remote
forensic tools as an investigative measure. The ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Text (Art.
27) provides that a judge may authorize a police officer to utilize ‘remote forensic software’ for a specific
task required for an investigation. More generally, the Council of Europe Child Protection
Convention (Art 30(5)) also refers to the obligation to take necessary legislative and other measures
in order to allow, where appropriate, for the possibility of ‘covert operations.’
More than one-third of country respondents to the Study questionnaire did not provide an
answer regarding the existence of legislation authorizing the use of remote forensic tools in law
enforcement investigations. Of
Figure 5.9: Use of remote forensics tools
those that did, almost half
12%
reported that no such power
32%
existed. For the other half of
Cyber‐specific powers
respondents that indicated such
General powers
powers were included in
legislation, the majority referred
Both
to a general power, rather than a
8%
Neither
cyber-specific
power.
48%
Comments
provided
by
countries ranged from explicitly
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q50. (n=40)
stating that ‘there are no legislative
provisions for… use of remote forensic tools’, to confirming that national law ‘permits the installation of a data
surveillance device.’65 Other countries commented more generally that procedural frameworks provided,
in certain circumstances, for the use of ‘technical or scientific expertise’ in order to obtain information
required during an investigation.66
Direct law enforcement access to extra-territorial data
Global connectivity means that computer data relevant to law enforcement investigations –
both for cybercrime and crime in general – is increasingly found extraterritorially to the investigating
jurisdiction. As discussed in Chapter Seven (International cooperation), traditional formal means of
international cooperation may not be sufficiently timely to ensure access to extraterritorial volatile
63
64
65
66
See, for example, Gartner. 2012. Remote Forensics Report 2012.
Hay, B., Nance, K., Bishop, M. 2009. Live Analysis: Progress and Challenges. IEEE Security and Privacy, 7(2):32.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51.
Ibid.
132
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents