CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS suspect is unaware that information is being collected,76 and even where the mere existence of legislation providing for investigative powers entails such a threat.77 As with a number of other rights, privacy rights in international law are not absolute and are subject to limitations – including, in the case of the ECHR, specifically for ‘the prevention of disorder or crime.’78 In this respect, safeguards in criminal procedure law such as the definition of the conditions and circumstances under which investigative powers can be used; the identity of authorizing officials; the manner of authorization; and the length of time investigative measures may be applied, are critical to the human rights assessment of whether criminal investigations that infringe privacy are acceptable as lawful and necessary.79 When it comes to the investigation of cybercrime, each investigative measure must be assessed in its own legal and practical context, in order to determine whether its interference with the privacy, family, home or correspondence of its subject is justified. While the often covert and/or electronic surveillance nature of cybercrime investigative techniques may raise particular privacy challenges,80 it is important to remember that the proportionality requirements of privacy rights apply equally to ‘simple’ search and seizure measures.81 Procedural law limits and safeguards must therefore reflect the varying intrusiveness of investigative measures – ensuring that each measure is only used as necessary in a democratic society. Existence of privacy protections and procedural safeguards During information gathering for the Study, countries responded to questions about the legal protection of privacy in the context of computer data or electronic communication and about how privacy rights function as safeguards during law enforcement investigations. Countries were also asked under what circumstances privacy rights may be restricted for the purposes of detecting and investigating cybercrime, and about extra-jurisdictional and international cooperation-related elements of privacy rights. Almost all responding countries indicated that privacy protections applied in the context of computer data and electronic communications. The way in which such protections are enshrined in law, however, showed considerable differences. Many countries referred to generic constitutional privacy rights which were also applied to computer data. A few countries even highlighted the ‘technologically neutral’ approach of privacy rights in their national law. Others cited specific legislation, including ‘privacy’ acts; ‘privacy protection’ laws; ‘telecommunications regulatory’ acts; ‘protection of privacy in electronic communications’ acts; ‘criminal code’ offences on invasion of privacy; ‘search and surveillance’ acts; ‘confidentiality of correspondence’ laws; and ‘communications secrets acts.’82 Some countries referenced international instruments, such as the ECHR, as sources of national privacy protections. A few countries stated explicitly that they had no ‘general’ privacy 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 See ECtHR Application No. 8691/79. See ECtHR Application No. 54934/00. See, for example, EHCR Article 8(2) which provides that ‘There shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of this right except such as in accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.’ The general approach adopted by the United Nations Human Rights Committee is to ask whether an interference with privacy is provided for by law, is in accordance with the provisions, aims and objectives of the Covenant and is reasonable in the particular circumstances of the case (See United Nations Human Rights Committee. Communication CCPR/C/82/D/903/1999 and Human Rights Committee. General Comment No. 16.) The approach of the ECtHR in law enforcement investigations cases is to ask (i) whether there was an interference with the privacy rights protected by Article 8 ECHR; (ii) whether the interference was in accordance with law – including not only the basis in domestic law but also the ‘quality’ of the law, in terms of its accessibility, foreseeability and compatibility with the rule of law; and (iii) whether the interference was necessary in a democratic society (See ECtHR Application No. 62540/00). See for example, UNODC. 2009. Current practices in electronic surveillance in the investigation of serious and organized crime. See for example, ECtHR Application No. 13710/88. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q21. 135

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents