law. Nonetheless, computer data and electronic communications in these countries was reported to
benefit from protections such as confidentiality and legal professional privilege laws.83
A number of countries confirmed that privacy protections were applicable in the context of
law enforcement investigations, but highlighted that privacy had to be balanced against the need to
prevent and investigate crime. While some countries described how this balance was achieved, the
majority of countries referred only to the requirements for warrants or judicial or prosecutorial
authority for intrusive searches or monitoring. One country highlighted that national law specified
that ‘due care shall be exercised [during search and seizure] in order to prevent the disclosure of private circumstances
not connected with the criminal proceedings.’84 Another noted that wiretapping of communications must be
used only as a ‘supplementary’ means of facilitating a criminal investigation. Some countries
highlighted, in particular, that data protection laws (which function as an important means of
protecting privacy in the context of personal data controlled and processed by third parties)
contained exclusions allowing, for example, third parties to disclose information to a law
enforcement agency where ‘reasonably necessary’ for the enforcement of criminal law.85
Further detail about the nature of procedural safeguards that help secure human rights and
respect for privacy during the investigative process was also requested by the Study questionnaire
from law enforcement officials. In response to this question, the majority of states (85 per cent)
specified that national limits and safeguards existed for law enforcement investigative cybercrime
measures.86 Surprisingly, therefore, a few countries stated that safeguards did not exist – a situation
which may lead to incompatibility with international human rights law.
Reported safeguards included restrictions on the types of computer data that may be
accessed by law enforcement, as well as supervision of investigative measures by the court or
prosecutor. Some states also
referred to time limits placed on
Figure 5.11: Limits and safeguards on investigations
the
use
of
investigative
Europe
measures.87 Other countries cited
(r=22)
Restrictions on the type
protective regimes including
of data that may be
accessed
limitations on access to computer
Asia & Oceania
Supervision of the
(r=20)
data once acquired by law
measure by the court or
prosecutor
enforcement, limitations on its
Time limits on the use of
a measure
Americas
use, destruction requirements, and
(r=10)
Other safeguards
internal
and
independent
oversight mechanisms.88 One
Africa
country reported that ‘A wide
(r=9)
variety of limits and safeguards apply,
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
with different limitations and safeguard
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire Q100. (n=45, r=61)
regimes being applied to each access
83
84
85
86
87
88
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q100.
Ibid.
Ibid. It should be noted, in addition, that countries in the European Union are subject to Council Framework Decision
2008/977/JHA of 27 November 2008 on the protection of personal data processed in the framework of police and judicial
cooperation in criminal matters, which regulates the processing of personal data by such authorities.
136
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents